Win now trade?

[0PucksGiven]

I sent :
Galchenyuk
Deharnais
Toffoli

I get:
Skinner
Couture
Callahan

So I sent this trade this morning, I believe this is a good win now trade for me with our league settings (cats and team in sig).

Let me know what you think. He hasn't accepted the trade yet so I still have some time to cancel if need be.

[0PucksGiven]

Trade still in limbo

[Pengwin7]

Interesting trade.
Obviously the kids (Galch & Toffoli) are off to hot starts... but they can both continue those.
I've never been a Skinner fan & Callahan seems buried in depth in Tampa Bay and I'm starting to wonder if he doesn't start to go the way of the B.Morrow: gritty leader that goes old quickly in a reduced role.

I don't know... I kinda feel like you should keep AG/DD/TT.

[ntrspctv]

while I usually agree with Pengwin, I disagree with him this time, except for skinner. couture is a win now and later player, and callahan is quite valuable in your league. hes been having success playing on top line and pp1 and I think will have a career year... worst case scenario, he bumps to second line with two young studs and remains on pp1.

desharnais... meh. Galchenyuk is a decent add, but Toffoli is the hot piece in that deal. Having Couture on the other side makes me doubt if I would accept that offer at all if I was offered your offer.

[0PucksGiven]

Hmm, I guess the main thing is can the kids I'm giving away keep producing

[The Bottlenecker]

I think anyone will be hard pressed to get Galchenyuk soon. Despite Montreals woes lately including last night's spanking by Calgary, Galchenyuk has looked very good. I would keep him and send Toffoli and Desharnais for Couture and Skinner. Hell I would probably send TT and DD for Couture by himself.

[JimmyMac]

I'm also not sure I'd move Gally if I were you. He's looked so dynamic and strong on the puck this year. I really think he'll develop into a special player. So many times he turns a nothing play into a scoring chance.