Galchenyuk for Skinner

[0PucksGiven]

I got offered Skinner for my Galchenyuk, what do you think? It's a keep 8 league and I'm in win now mode.

[rainydrinkwater]

I'd take this deal in a limited keeper such as this league.

[mister_mcgoo]

kind of a toss up really...Skinner is better for G/PPP/SOG...Galchenyuk better for +/-,A,Hits
Skinner will likely outscore Galchenyuk this year, but he's also a bandaid boy and frequently injured (and on an awful team with tons of other injuries)...I might go with Galy

[0PucksGiven]

Hmm, he is starting to back down now.

[Instant Karma]

Hmm, he is starting to back down now.

He may have heard that Skinner might return sooner rather than later...

[0PucksGiven]

Hmm any other opinions guys?

- - - Updated - - -

Offer is still on the table

[PrairieDog]

Even with the injury risk, I like Skinner here. Galchenyuk is solid, but IMO Skinner's upside is higher.

[Magicstew]

keep Galchenyuk - Skinner too much of a bandaid.
Find a Mtl fan to trade him too.

[Atomic Wedgy]

I would not trade Galchenyuk for Skinner. No way.... Far too risky a proposition.

[The Bottlenecker]

Galchenyuk's upside, which we may even see this season, is too high to give him up for the perennial Band Aid Boy, Skinner, even if he can score when he is healthy.

[0PucksGiven]

Ok boys, I'm keeping Galchenyuk. Thanks for the advice

[rainydrinkwater]

Thing is, it's a keep 8 and both Skinner and Galchenyuk are unlikely to make the cut for next year so it's really about who can help more this year. I still think Skinner is a better bet to produce for this year.

[Front89]

Exactly my thoughts too...Skinner is not likely a keeper for the OP so its all about production for this year. IF Skinner stays healthy (I know a big IF), he likely out-produces Galchenyuk