Do it. Phaneuf is a more proven player on a somewhat better team.
I was suggested this in another thread...but am reluctant...am I nuts? Do it?
ESPN 8-Team H2H Points
C(2) LW(2) RW(2) D(4) UTL(3) G(2) B(11) IR(4)
G(4) A(2) +/-(1) PIM(.25) SOG(.25) SHG(2) SHA(1) GWG(3) HAT(8) HIT(.25) BLK(.25) DEF(1) PPP(1)
W(5) L(-2) SA(.1) GA(-1) SV(.2) SO(5) OTL(2)
C: McDavid(K), Barzal, Kadri, Suzuki, Hischier, Keller, Teravainen
LW: Huberdeau, Robertson, Verhaeghe, Caufield, Benn
RW: Kucherov (K), Fiala, Thomas, Thompson, Jarvis, Necas
D: Josi, Heiskenan, Dahlin, Hamilton, Hronek
G: Oettinger, Fleury, Talbot
IR: Andersen
Do it. Phaneuf is a more proven player on a somewhat better team.
10 Team One Year H2H Non-Playoff League
Skaters: G, A, +/-, STP, ATOI, SOG, BLK, DEF Pts.
Goalies: W, SO, Svs., SV%, GAA
Daily Roster 9 Forwards 5 Defence 2 Goalies 2 UTIL count.
F - Seguin, Voracek, Ladd, Little, Cammalleri, Panarin, Domi, Barkov, Nelson, Zucker, Monahan, Koivu, Draisaitl, Couture (IR)
D - Carlson, Faulk, Ekblad, Vatanen, Lindholm, Krug
G - Luongo, Jones, Rask
ESPN 8-Team H2H Points
C(2) LW(2) RW(2) D(4) UTL(3) G(2) B(11) IR(4)
G(4) A(2) +/-(1) PIM(.25) SOG(.25) SHG(2) SHA(1) GWG(3) HAT(8) HIT(.25) BLK(.25) DEF(1) PPP(1)
W(5) L(-2) SA(.1) GA(-1) SV(.2) SO(5) OTL(2)
C: McDavid(K), Barzal, Kadri, Suzuki, Hischier, Keller, Teravainen
LW: Huberdeau, Robertson, Verhaeghe, Caufield, Benn
RW: Kucherov (K), Fiala, Thomas, Thompson, Jarvis, Necas
D: Josi, Heiskenan, Dahlin, Hamilton, Hronek
G: Oettinger, Fleury, Talbot
IR: Andersen
If the league counts things like PIMs, SOGs and hits, I'd take Phaneuf easily. Points only, I think it's a closer call but I'd still favor Phaneuf.
14 Team H2H Dynasty League (14 keepers, no farm)
Weekly Starts (3C, 5W, 5D, 1Util, 2G)
G, A, PPP, SOG, BS, +/-, GAA, W+OTL, SV%
C: MacKinnon/Eichel/Kopitar/Pinto/Wright
W: Ovechkin/Toffoli/Necas/Giroux/E.Kane/K.Johnson/Schmaltz/Bjorkstrand
D: Dobson/Trouba/Mintyukov/Gostisbehere/Edvinsson/York
G: Saros/Demko/Askarov
I'd definitely drop Pitkanen to pick up Phaneuf.
Ok did as was suggested...I think my team is set for a while now. But eventually I need to figure out who to drop for Kesler.
ESPN 8-Team H2H Points
C(2) LW(2) RW(2) D(4) UTL(3) G(2) B(11) IR(4)
G(4) A(2) +/-(1) PIM(.25) SOG(.25) SHG(2) SHA(1) GWG(3) HAT(8) HIT(.25) BLK(.25) DEF(1) PPP(1)
W(5) L(-2) SA(.1) GA(-1) SV(.2) SO(5) OTL(2)
C: McDavid(K), Barzal, Kadri, Suzuki, Hischier, Keller, Teravainen
LW: Huberdeau, Robertson, Verhaeghe, Caufield, Benn
RW: Kucherov (K), Fiala, Thomas, Thompson, Jarvis, Necas
D: Josi, Heiskenan, Dahlin, Hamilton, Hronek
G: Oettinger, Fleury, Talbot
IR: Andersen