Would you trade Berglund for Setoguchi?

[agentzero]

Full keeper, every year for life. Pts only, no positions among Fs.

Would you guys pull the trigger, in trading away Berglund for Setoguchi? Both are struggling. It all hinges on this question:

Is Berglund the next Sundin, or the next Antropov?

Any thoughts appreciated. Thanks everyone!

[Harnish]

Personally I'd hang onto Berglund. Setoguchi is a good player but could possibly be the next Cheechoo if he doesn't play with Thornton on a consistent basis. Being a big leafs fan I can appreciate your analogy! I think Berglund is the next Sundin (although Antropov is doing ok this year, did ok last year too!).

[Shoeless]

I sure wouldn't make that move - it might be oh so wrong but I am not convinced that Setoguchi is the ultimate sniper. I would keep Berglund and hope it covers his hype.

[TundraArc]

Setoguchi is hard to peg right now as he's being bounced around on different lines. Unless he starts clicking soon I would expect Marleau and Heatley to keep taking time away from Setoguchi. The funny part is the better the 2nd, 3rd and 4th lines do in terms of points the more likely Seto will get edged out over the Thornton, Marleau and Heatley line. I think a lot of his value will depend on if Marleau gets moved or not and who they get in return. With Patty out it would open a spot up for Seto to get in the top line more consistently.
I've read in the local paper that the plan is to move Setoguchi up slowly but personally the chemisty with the top 3 really puts him in a bind.

[agentzero]

tundra, those were exactly my concerns. Thanks for the input guys, I guess I'll stand pat on Berglund. It may take him (gulp) 4 years to hit the numbers I'm waiting for, but I guess that is the nature of fantasy hockey sometimes...