Hmm, I think the trade is even. I think Parise and Heatley will finish with similar numbers, but it really now depends on who YOU like more and who you will replace Neidermayer with.
So it looks like you can replace Neidermayer with either Robidas or McCabe or even Edler, so if you really want Heatley then I dont think you would be dumb for trading Parise and Neidermayer for him.
I think you may want other people's opinions because I think it's a fair deal. Either player would be good.