Elias or Giroux

[Fighting_Emu]

It IS a keeper but I posted here because I am really a lot more concerned with who wins this year as I am set up nicely for a shot at the title.

Take Elias proven track record of steady production

or

Gamble on Giroux's immense upside?

I know these boards have a tendency to be biased towards youth but I think this is a lot closer than many people on here might think...

[AngryJerk]

Elias is dealing with groin injuries, I would go with Giroux - he's even got a chance at making the top line if they end up dealing Briere

[immortal_leafs]

I think Giroux's value is only slightly less than Elias's at present, given that Lemaire is back in NJ and Giroux may get top line minute as AngryJerk mentioned - plus your team is very young, so it's not like this is all or nothing, you look to be very competitive for years to come. For me this is a simple decision: Giroux all the way.

[Nieuwendyk]

Giroux please.
Elias out 3-6 weeks. Give him a couple of weeks to get in game shape when he gets back. By the time the end of the season comes, I wouldn't be surprised if Giroux beats Elias this year.

[natgeo]

The others have said it: groin injury for Elias and Lemaire in NJ.

Giroux for me, too.

[tequilamonster]

even without smellyass groin injury.....its rooooooooooooooooooooooooo all the way....

[mister_mcgoo]

give me Giroux too, gotta go big