Franzen, M Koivu, Vanek, for ? end results :)

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

Franzen, M Koivu, Vanek, for Datsuk, Chara

And my 1st round waiver pick for his 2nd round pick which will work out to be a good goalie.



What do you guys think about this trade fair? unfair?

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

bump

[newper114]

its very close in my mind. hard to tell. you losing that first rounder might be my push to say no.

also im a big believer in koivu i think he could dance around a ppg if thats the case then i think him vanek and a 1st rounder will go furthur than chara and datsuk.. but then again you do need an upgrade in your dman keeper... so like i said tuff call. too many positives and negatives for me to say what to do.

[smack]

I really like this trade for you. You\'d be getting 2 superstars and giving up 1. I wouldn\'t lose too much sleeping over losing Franzen and Koivu (both seem to get injured quite a bit) and Vanek is a stud but you have to give up something of significant value for Datsyuk and Chara.

I like it and my opinion would be to take it.

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

I should mention I have the last places teams 1st pick also so it is not like i am totally losing first round pick.

I sent this same offer for these players just now let me know if I am being realistic.

Backstrom/Boyle, Carter/Phaneuf, Getlaf/Bowmeister, Thornton/Weidman, Malkin,

I hope somebody accepts I think I am offering a decent trade considering they get a very good goalie in the trade with my pick. I think people are scared because of Vaneks injury but he is only going to miss maybe 6-8 more games.

Thanks for the comments everyone

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

I am also going to add to each offer either McDonlad or Connolly

So the deal I have sent out to 5 different managers

Vanek
Franzen
M. Koivu
* 2009 1st round pick
Connolly or MacDonald

For

Carter/Phaneuf & 2nd round pick
Getzlaf/Bowmeister & 2nd round pick
Datsyuk/Chara & 2nd round pick
Thornton/Weidman or Malkin & 5th round pick
Backstrom/Boyle and 4th round pick

Which of these do you think will/wont happen.

To make it interesting for all take a guess and I\'ll post back what happens.

Please keep sending comments

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

^^

[Cruisin4aBruisin]

Ok so after all the above trades were either not answered or rejected I almost gave up trying to make any more moves then this was offered to me today so I took it.

Markov
Alfie
\'09 2nd rd prospect pick

for Vanek


What do you think?