Robertson or Stutzle

[Patty93]

Both elite talents, who would you rather own as a keeper going forward in an all cats league? (No faceoffs and no positions)

Robertson had the better season, but seems slow to produce this year, is he more of a 80-90 point guy then a 100 point guy? And Stutzle seems so dynamic on the ice and offers good peripherals.

Thoughts?

[2014olympicgold]

I'm going to lean Stutzle. I think Robertson is closer to a 90pt guy than a 100pt guy.

If it's a straight points league it's a cointoss I think most years.
If it's a goal heavy league it's Robertson most years.
If hits are involved it's Stutzle I think....
If it's a cap league I would lean Stutzle as he's locked in really long term at $8.25m(?).

I think from the amount of views, and lack of posts, it shows how tight this is. If someone offered me Stutzle for Robertson, I would come here and ask and if I got a split consensus I would just stick with what I have.

[Belexus75]

yeah it is close but i would also lean Stutzle...mostly based on personal preference but i also agree that more cats you add more it swings towards Stutzle

[senryu]

My gut says Stutzle, but I have no strong feeling either way.

[TheDard]

I am partial to Stutzle over Robertson.

I think his upside is higher and the better floor.

[MJ Flex]

I'm going to lean Stutzle. I think Robertson is closer to a 90pt guy than a 100pt guy.

If it's a straight points league it's a cointoss I think most years.
If it's a goal heavy league it's Robertson most years.
If hits are involved it's Stutzle I think....
If it's a cap league I would lean Stutzle as he's locked in really long term at $8.25m(?).

I think from the amount of views, and lack of posts, it shows how tight this is. If someone offered me Stutzle for Robertson, I would come here and ask and if I got a split consensus I would just stick with what I have.

I agree with this.

[stevegamer]

Give me Stutzle in most formats.

I think this favors goals, but has hits, so it's super close, and would lean Stutzle due to what changes could show up.

[Kreids Fan]

I think both are extremely talented and relatively close. I would also take Stutzle , but I don’t think you can go wrong here.