Massive trade, who won?

[Dr.Brad]

Who won this trade?

12 team league, bangers, +/- counts, no FOW

Team one receives: Stutzle, ErikssonEk, Keller, Barzal, J.Gaudreau, O’Reilly

Team two receives: Meier, F.Forsberg, Hartman, Byfield, Norris, Hayton

[Feenom]

I like team 1. They got the best player. JEE and Keller are good pickups as well.

[Belexus75]

yeah i like pieces on both sides but Stutzle side wins mostly because of him...absolute stud.

[2014olympicgold]

Team 1 got the best player. Then some names
Team 2 is more balanced.

I would likely side with team 1, but JG shouldn't be rostered. Barzal is also kind of a hamper for a banger team. Keller needs to be a 90pt player to be useful in a banger. ROR is meh in my opinion.

Team 2 is def more balanced, and it might end up tipping to that side depending on how you feel about Byfield

[random-d]

Team 1 got the best player. Then some names
Team 2 is more balanced.

I would likely side with team 1, but JG shouldn't be rostered. Barzal is also kind of a hamper for a banger team. Keller needs to be a 90pt player to be useful in a banger. ROR is meh in my opinion.

Team 2 is def more balanced, and it might end up tipping to that side depending on how you feel about Byfield

This is a solid analysis and I tend to agree. In a banger league with no FOW I would probably like team 2 more.

[BloodSport]

Why do I see a clear Team #2 win here?

No, I am not Team #2, but I’d want to be.

[IRSlotsFull]

I am the other manager from the trade.

I liked what we were able to do, I think (speaking 3 hours post trade and wondering when/if the remorse will hit).
Though it started as an ask about Barrett Hayton, it grew from there looking at positions, teams, rankings (actual and theoretical), and age - we are a tiered keepers league.
Stutzle didn't even come into it until we were 4 bodies each side.

Figured to mention we're 4C/4L/4R/6D/2G/5B formatted (2IR & 1NA also) - so this was roughly 1/4th of each teams rostered skaters.
In a perfect league (all rosters filled) that's 336 players - though our typical 'highest available' player is around rank 150-160 and belongs to whomever has the highest PIM.

Keep the ideas coming - we're looking at a 1 round (conditional) pick to the loser based on your thoughts!

[tweetdrivr]

Team 1 by a mile. Not even close. Some decent names on team 2 but man is team 1 is far better.
Quick summary
Stutzle: 100+ point upside, pacing for 100+ hits, budding superstar.
Eriksson Ek: PPG player pacing for 150 hits
Keller: 90+ point upside with potential for more as Arizona gels and matures
Barzal, Gaudreau, O’Reilly - meh but will still be solid with some big positive regression potential in Gaudreau
Average age of players involved: 26

Meier: hits but square peg in a round hole in NJ. Will never be what he was in SJ no matter how much guys pump his tires.
Forsberg: PPG player, 125ish hits. Like Ericksson Ek but 3 years older and some injury history
Hartman: 65-75 points, pacing for 100+ hits
Byfield: budding potential. Unknown ceiling, but not Stutzle level.
Norris: 75-80 point player. Significant injury history.
Hayton: sophomore slump or better in real life than fantasy. Had 43 in 82 last year with a hot finish. Real gamble.
Average age of players: 25.5

Team 1 please. If nothing else it’s Best Player In the Deal in Stutzle.

[PenguinHunter]

Team 1 by a mile. Not even close. Some decent names on team 2 but man is team 1 is far better.
Quick summary
Stutzle: 100+ point upside, pacing for 100+ hits, budding superstar.
Eriksson Ek: PPG player pacing for 150 hits
Keller: 90+ point upside with potential for more as Arizona gels and matures
Barzal, Gaudreau, O’Reilly - meh but will still be solid with some big positive regression potential in Gaudreau
Average age of players involved: 26

Meier: hits but square peg in a round hole in NJ. Will never be what he was in SJ no matter how much guys pump his tires.
Forsberg: PPG player, 125ish hits. Like Ericksson Ek but 3 years older and some injury history
Hartman: 65-75 points, pacing for 100+ hits
Byfield: budding potential. Unknown ceiling, but not Stutzle level.
Norris: 75-80 point player. Significant injury history.
Hayton: sophomore slump or better in real life than fantasy. Had 43 in 82 last year with a hot finish. Real gamble.
Average age of players: 25.5

Team 1 please. If nothing else it’s Best Player In the Deal in Stutzle.

This is great analysis.

I am not sure there is much to add to the above.

Stutzle is so much better than Meier and Forsberg that you win by a landslide on the best player available.

And then you have secondary pieces that are very good as well.

Adding Gaudreau in a banger league is meh... but he is just a throw in and not the main reason Team one makes this trade.

[finnys_fanatsy]

Team 1 by a mile. Not even close. Some decent names on team 2 but man is team 1 is far better.
Quick summary
Stutzle: 100+ point upside, pacing for 100+ hits, budding superstar.
Eriksson Ek: PPG player pacing for 150 hits
Keller: 90+ point upside with potential for more as Arizona gels and matures
Barzal, Gaudreau, O’Reilly - meh but will still be solid with some big positive regression potential in Gaudreau
Average age of players involved: 26

Meier: hits but square peg in a round hole in NJ. Will never be what he was in SJ no matter how much guys pump his tires.
Forsberg: PPG player, 125ish hits. Like Ericksson Ek but 3 years older and some injury history
Hartman: 65-75 points, pacing for 100+ hits
Byfield: budding potential. Unknown ceiling, but not Stutzle level.
Norris: 75-80 point player. Significant injury history.
Hayton: sophomore slump or better in real life than fantasy. Had 43 in 82 last year with a hot finish. Real gamble.
Average age of players: 25.5

Team 1 please. If nothing else it’s Best Player In the Deal in Stutzle.

couldnt have said it better...AIAEC