Hart or Binnington

[sportsnut]

Which would you go with ROY and as a keeper going forward?

[pmorrow]

Binnington ROY, after that...it gets complicated. If you want to be really risk aversive, Binnington. But Hart should get it together and he will most likely blow right past Binnington at some point. But there could be more growing pains ahead. That's not an easy call right now, although Hart could make the decision easy if he returns to some semblance of form down the stretch (team in front of him needs to be better).

What is the context? Are you trying to buy low on Hart? Sell Hart for Binnington to make a run at a title?

[sportsnut]

I have Hart and it was more about run for title. We can only keep 1 goalie and other goalies are Lehner and Talbot.

[stevegamer]

I'm not sure I'd keep either of them over Lehner, as it depends how the offseason shakes out for Lehner.

For rest of this year, give me Binnington. The Flyers have issues that the GM can't fix at a trade deadline, short of him resigning and being replaced by a better GM.