D for D? Rasmus Dahlin vs Dougie Hamilton straight up?

[Joe_Sakic19]

Curious which side wins or if this is a decent trade for both sides?

G, A, PPP, SOG, GWG, HITS, BLKS, PIM, +/-
Plus goalie cats.

Dougie is the superior player but how many Dahlins are there in the league at his age with his pedigree? Win win?

I can’t tell which side I like better. All opinions welcome. Thx

[Smurf54]

I have both, with similar stats categories. Hamilton, right now, is a much better player with your categories. Having said that, I'm a big believer in in Dahlin, and believe he will be a rare pt/gm Dman. It's hard to say for sure without knowing the rest of your roster (or the other GMs roster). But in most cases, I would choose Hamilton - especially if you are competing now. If you're rebuilding though, I could see an argument for going with Dahlin.

[stevegamer]

Hamilton is better in your categories.

[metaldude26]

Is Dahlin ever gonna be a big time multi-cat producer? I choose Dougie. You might be able to make this trade after this season, when Dahlin may be better situated to break out.

[hockeyrobot]

Curious which side wins or if this is a decent trade for both sides?

G, A, PPP, SOG, GWG, HITS, BLKS, PIM, +/-
Plus goalie cats.

Dougie is the superior player but how many Dahlins are there in the league at his age with his pedigree? Win win?

I can’t tell which side I like better. All opinions welcome. Thx

It's a decent trade assuming one team is competing and the other is rebuilding. But there is no guarantee Dahlin ever reaches Hamilton's level so I side with Dougie.