Marner vs. W. Nylander

[GSD]

Nylander for me too. Can get him much lower in the draft too.

[Sidenown]

I would take nylander in a keeper. While I think that Marner is the slightly better talent, and I would pick him if I was running a real team, I think Nylander's place playing with Matthews and the fact that he shoots more and will likely score more goals makes me lean towards him. While I think Marner has the higher ceiling I think its marginal and I think playing with Matthews makes Nylanders floor in fantasy higher than Marner's

[Stokens]

I've heard a few times Marner is more likely to regress this year. His luck stats (don't remember their name) indicated he was luckier last year and Nylander was actually a bit unlucky and could provide more this year than he did last.

I'd say Nylander

[DusterDave]

I also owned both last year in my keeper league. Traded Nylander to a fellow Leafs fan and while we were in trade talks, he didn't seem to have a preference, he just wanted one of them so I opted to sell Nylander and keep Marner.
But initial reaction would be flip of a coin. I noticed that most 'experts' have Nylander ranked higher, and that of course is because he plays on Matthews wing. I have a sense that Marner could really surprise and drop some jaws in the coming seasons though. I think he has a higher, unexpected ceiling than Nylander. I'll go Marner.

[forsbergfan]

this year nylander, long term marner. he's gonna be the leafs version of patrick kane. I see nylander as a 70 point player while marner has the potential for even more.

[butch]

Flip a coin, I have them that close.

One of these guys is the 3rd best player on the Leafs. Man that's a nice thought

until tavares arrives july 2018

[Belexus75]

i think its a coin drop, but Marner holds more value as of now from what i seen...i think its more of North American vs European and not based on what they accomplished so fat but still i woudl take a guy here that holds most value...production wise one can be better then the other in any given year

[The Black Panther]

Real toughie. The fact that Nylander plays with AM evens this out for me

[The Black Panther]

I also owned both last year in my keeper league. Traded Nylander to a fellow Leafs fan and while we were in trade talks, he didn't seem to have a preference, he just wanted one of them so I opted to sell Nylander and keep Marner.
But initial reaction would be flip of a coin. I noticed that most 'experts' have Nylander ranked higher, and that of course is because he plays on Matthews wing. I have a sense that Marner could really surprise and drop some jaws in the coming seasons though. I think he has a higher, unexpected ceiling than Nylander. I'll go Marner.

What did u get for Nylander?