Rank these goalie

[Mytaniel007]

Hello guys, keeper league with salary cap 75m (real salary). How would you rank these goalie.
Talbot bobrovsky dubnyk price quick jones crawford bishop rask schneider anderson.
They are all available at the draft and only 8 pooler needs a goalie.
I could have the option of keeping talbot since i can keep 2 of talbot d strome and puljujarvi, but with the amount of goalies available, i think i dont loose much compared to loosing 1 of the 2 prospects.
What do you think?

[Wonko]

Tough to rank goalies like this. So many variables and wild cards that is why tiers are often more appropriate.

Here is a tentative order for you IMHO.

Tier 1

Price
Talbot

Tier 2

Dubnyk
Jones
Rask
Crawford
Bishop
Bob
Quick
Schneider
Anderson

[TheBends]

Based on performance and cost next season I would go with this list.

Dubnyk
Crawford
Quick
Talbot

[RizzeeDizzee]

What categories? That's very key, as is how many goalie categories there are vs. skater categories. Also, you say you can keep Talbot - but what if you don't? Who would you get to keep instead? How do your skaters look? What pick would you have?

If only 8 teams need goalies, one approach would be to focus entirely on skaters and let others reach for netminders, then settle on someone after most of the other teams have reached. You'll still be able to get a guy like Rask or Andersen, who might be as good at the 3rd guy taken much earlier.

When Dobber's guide comes out be sure to buy it - there's a very good system of "tiering" goalies. It's a very key concept.

[lucafen4]

Based on performance and cost next season I would go with this list.

Dubnyk
Crawford
Quick
Talbot

interesting Carey Price doesn't make your short list. Are you a Leafs fan too?

[TheBends]

interesting Carey Price doesn't make your short list. Are you a Leafs fan too?

I am from Toronto but I don't consider myself a true fan of any team. I only really got into hockey a few years ago, so I have favourite players and teams I enjoy watching. The Leafs are definitely an existing team to watch now! haha

I didn't include Price because he's going to cost too much next season. In our league we only use 3 goalie categories, so that would mean Price would cost $3.5m a cat. Insanity

[Call of Doughty]

Tough to rank goalies like this. So many variables and wild cards that is why tiers are often more appropriate.

Here is a tentative order for you IMHO.

Tier 1

Price
Talbot

Tier 2

Dubnyk
Jones
Rask
Crawford
Bishop
Bob
Quick

Schneider
Anderson

I like this list. Yes keep Talbot if you can.

I am from Toronto but I don't consider myself a true fan of any team. I only really got into hockey a few years ago, so I have favourite players and teams I enjoy watching. The Leafs are definitely an existing team to watch now! haha

I didn't include Price because he's going to cost too much next season. In our league we only use 3 goalie categories, so that would mean Price would cost $3.5m a cat. Insanity

Just to clarify, Price maintains his 6.5M contract this season, and then the 10.5M kicks in in 2018-19. So he maintains great value going into this season.

[TheBends]

I like this list. Yes keep Talbot if you can.



Just to clarify, Price maintains his 6.5M contract this season, and then the 10.5M kicks in in 2018-19. So he maintains great value going into this season.

Ya, I know. But I wouldn't want to be stuck with that price tag next season, so I would rather a goalie that is close to Price but will be half the cost next year.

[lucafen4]

Ya, I know. But I wouldn't want to be stuck with that price tag next season, so I would rather a goalie that is close to Price but will be half the cost next year.

you're being awful nice to someone who appears to be in the same league as you.. heh. I'd be tempted to put Price at the top of the list to lure him into cap trouble

[TheBends]

Haha he's not in my league. All of those goalies mentioned are taken.

[Mytaniel007]

Sorry for the missing details, not used to the signature thing. 23 roster. 12 f 6 d 1 g counts
Goaler counts for 2 pts/ w 5 pts / so. We can keep some players 2 3 or 4 years max. I thought the gap between talbot and another i could draft would be lower than the gap between strome and a late pick.