Tyler Seguin trade or keep?

[DudeImJason]

2 days ago I posted in my leagues FB group that Tyler Seguin was available and I've been sent several trade offers thoughts on if any are worth it or hold onto Seguin, team & league stats in SIG, (numbers in brackets equal avg PPG)

A) Seguin(3.8) for Marner(3.2) + Ehlers(3.1)

B) Seguin(3.8) + Dubois for Skinner(3.6) + Drouin(3.0) + Keller

C) Seguin(3.8) + Gallagher(2.6) for Simmonds(4.0) + Duchene(2.7)

D) Seguin(3.8) + Fabbri(2.6) for Pavelski(4.1) + Tkachuk(2.9)

E) Seguin(3.8) for Granlund(3.4) + Mark Stone(3.2)

[Nehithaw]

2 days ago I posted in my leagues FB group that Tyler Seguin was available and I've been sent several trade offers thoughts on if any are worth it or hold onto Seguin, team & league stats in SIG, (have open spot so won't have to drop someone in 2for1 deals, & numbers in brackets equal avg PPG)

A) Seguin(3.8) for Marner(3.2) + Ehlers(3.1)

B) Seguin(3.8) + Dubois for Skinner(3.6) + Drouin(3.0) + Keller

C) Seguin(3.8) + Gallagher(2.6) for Simmonds(4.0) + Duchene(2.7)

D) Seguin(3.8) + Fabbri(2.6) for Pavelski(4.1) + Tkachuk(2.9)

E) Seguin(3.8) for Granlund(3.4) + Mark Stone(3.2)

I would do this one.

[LuigiC173]

yeah A is hard to pass up in keeper. Even option E is nice.

[MZac]

A is the only one id consider. Seguin should be a 4+ ppg next season. I probably just hold him.

[Eskimo Brother]

Assuming you would have to drop either Palmieri or Vatrano to do deal 1, I would pass for now.
Deal 1 is the only one I see as very close, so you could try building off it from there.

[Axeman33]

The fact you are getting that many offers should be a strong indicator that you should retain Seguin.

I do like offer A the best but once you factor in the need to drop another player removes the attraction.

[RizzeeDizzee]

Do A, then fist pump every time Hitchcock forces Seguin out on the PK

[forumname]

In a points only dynasty league like yours, I would have a hard time saying no to A.

[Nehithaw]

Ehlers, who just turned 21 years of age and has very talented line-mates that are trending upward, had 8 less points than Seguin.

Marner, a 19 year old rookie in his first season that has very talented line-mates that are trending upward, had 11 less points than someone that was drafted right around where Crosby was drafted - think about that one.

You are getting back some players that could both outpoint Seguin within 5 years, and possibly as soon as next season.

I wish that this site had a 'remind me bot' that can go back to older posts to see how things really went down after some time. Also, a report card of sorts for how often someone is right or wrong with their advice would be a cool feature ; similar to a winning percentage. Something like this would be a great tool to see things from an objective perspective to go with the Karma system that could be viewed as being more subjective.

[DudeImJason]

my league includes all stats aside from ATOI, shows in my sig, but yeah A has me debating with myself the most

In a points only dynasty league like yours, I would have a hard time saying no to A.

[forumname]

my league includes all stats aside from ATOI, shows in my sig, but yeah A has me debating with myself the most

Ahhh, I see. I saw "points dynasty" and missed the categories.

[havanablast21]

I agree with the others... A is the only enticing deal of the bunch. I would probably take that deal but I'm extremely high on Marner and quite high on Ehlers.

[Spinorama514]

I would have a tough, tough time passing up both Ehlers & Marner. The rest of the offers are not worth it, IMO.

[yougo]

Deal 1 is really hard to pass up but since you need to drop a player. I'd consider tweaking it a little bit.