Rantanen or Fabbri

[DudeImJason]

better keeper option Mikko Rantanen or Robby Fabbri?, all stats except ATOI (if Rantanen's -25 is a turn off, Fabbri was -16 and +/- is quite insignificant in my league)

[MZac]

Close call but I'm taking fabbri here on the better team

[GinFizz]

ill take Rantanen. higher upside long term.

[Axeman33]

Tough call because I love both kids.

Im going to say Fabbri but I wouldnt argue with the people who prefer Rantanen.

[Eskimo Brother]

Fabbri for me, but I agree with Axe's point that I wouldn't fault you for going with Rantanen.

[ericdaoust]

In a 16-team league there should be a trade market for these guys. Put them both on the block and sell one.

[DudeImJason]

if I had both I'd do that but I currently have Fabbri and was offered Rantanen for him so just contemplating if I should do this deal or not

In a 16-team league there should be a trade market for these guys. Put them both on the block and sell one.

[ericdaoust]

I'd go with Rantanen. Even if they're 5-10 points apart he'll be worth more.

[agentzero]

Pts only, Robby. Multicat, Mikko.

[Sulla]

For me I think Rantanen due to higher trade value but I do prefer Fabbri's supporting cast (but then maybe that is a reason not to go him as plenty of options for the Blues to shuffle things around whilst Rantanen could be one of the main guys)

[Jouko-Pouko]

Rantanen is more of a playmaker than a goal-scorer while Fabbri could be the better goal-scorer of the two of them. Just points, I like Rantanen more. Of course that's assuming Colorado is able to get their sh*t together but I think they will.

[finnys_fanatsy]

I like Rant here. i know teh Blues are a better squad, but i feel teh depth will hurt Fabbri.

[StamkosFan]

I like Rantanen more, while only slightly, he's younger, and has more of a chance to become a franchise player in a struggling squad like Colorado. Rantanen has higher prestige, and, in my opinion, a higher ceiling. Rantanen could easily be a 50+ points player next year

[RizzeeDizzee]

I'm going to say it - I'm not drinking the Rantanen kool-aid. Is he going to be a full time NHLer? Sure. Will he have a 20 goals season or two? Probably. But I'm not seeing the ingredients of a special player. To me, he's one of those players who'll be hyped, then propped up after he doesn't hit the ground running, then all of a sudden folks will realize he never amounted to anything.

Fabbri, on the other hand, has shown flashes of strong play. Plus, he was a stalwart for a while on PP1, and on a team as deep as St. Louis that will be key. I'm taking Fabbri here.