Defensemen - Rank Them - One Year Format

[gcefaloni]

Hi guys,

I need help from you guys in sorting the Ds that are available for my upcoming draft.
The league format is a cap league where salaries are the same as the NHL and cap hit for teams are also the same as NHL and counts Points (1pt) & +/- (+ or - 1pt); so a D that has 47 points but is -5 gets 42 Fantasy Pts and a D that gets 37 pts and is +5 also gets 42 FPs.

So here is the list to rank for a 1-year performance given the above format (pts and +/-):
Colton Parayko
Jake Muzzin
Kevin Klein
Mike Green
Matt Dumba
Cody Ceci
Dmitry Orlov
Danny DeKeyser
Jared Spurgeon
David Savard
Morgan Rielly

Thanks a ton guys! I know it's a long list and kinda funky rules where the team is super important on the FPs due to +/-

Looking forward to seeing your sorting/rankings and any short comments as to why would be super appreciated.

[Eskimo Brother]

Colton Parayko
Jake Muzzin
Morgan Rielly
Matt Dumba
Kevin Klein
Cody Ceci
Dmitry Orlov
David Savard
Jared Spurgeon
Danny DeKeyser
Mike Green

Just off the top of my head I think I would rank them something like this.

[PenguinHunter]

Colton Parayko - 1
Jake Muzzin - 2
Kevin Klein 7
Mike Green 8
Matt Dumba 3
Cody Ceci 6
Dmitry Orlov 4
Danny DeKeyser 10
Jared Spurgeon 9
David Savard 11
Morgan Rielly 5

[RizzeeDizzee]

With +/- being so key, Parayko is a monster. Muzzin is also the clear choice for second. After that it's a bit cloudier. I actually like Orlov for #3, especially with his "show me" one year deal and that fact that he's entering his fourth season. The next group would be Rielly, then Dumba, then Green, then Ceci. After that it's a mish-mosh of mediocrity or worse.

[gcefaloni]

Interesting how you guys put Dumba so high up. I'm always afraid Spurgeon will take the second spot on the 1st PP and that Dumba will end up with next to no PP points due to it. Suter is never losing his. About Orlov, is he going to be playing with Carlson on the PP? WSH plays 4 FWs and 1 D for PP right? (There are no extra PP points but I figure a lot of the total production of an offensive D comes from PP)

[Eskimo Brother]

Had Dumba higher because I think he can fall into that Shattenkirk role of D3-4 and PPQB. Maybe just not to the same lofty heights as Shatty has hit.

[Canucks_fan18]

Yikes! +/- is Critical. Here is my list then...

Colton Parayko
Jake Muzzin

Dmitry Orlov
Jared Spurgeon
Matt Dumba
Mike Green
Cody Ceci

Morgan Rielly
Danny DeKeyser
David Savard

Tiered out like that as well. I don't think Toronto is going to be that much better this year. I could see Morgan Reilly getting 40-45 points with -15 to -20 putting him at the 25-30 points range.