Need help with selecting 10 keepers

[tandsmurphy]

Team/league info in sig.
Goalies are tough to come by in this league. Was able to pick up both Murray and Vas off the bone pile last year. Are they keepable?
Have some tough decisions. IMHO i have more than 15+ guys I could keep. Who would you keep and who to try to deal (thinking picks)?
The more opinions the better! Thanks in advance!

[PenguinHunter]

C - Sidney Crosby, Evgeny Kuznetsov, Patrice Bergeron, Alex Galchenyuk
F - Patrick Kane, Johnny Gaudreau, Taylor Hall, Blake Wheeler, Phil Kessel, Andre Burakovsky
D - Justin Faulk, Keith Yandle, Shayne Gostisbehere
G - Tuukka Rask, Jimmy Howard, Andrei Vasilevskiy, Matt Murray, Andrew Hammond

I do not think you want to keep goalies that are not going to get decent amount of starts like Vas and Murray might this year.

[Kylegary Flames]

Crosby
Kuznetsov
Galchenyuk
Kane
Gaudreau
Hall
Wheeler
Faulk
Rask
Vasilevskiy

A case can be made to keep Kessel over Galchenyuk (I might be a little biased since I have Galchenyuk). I also like Faulk the best with your cats, but Ghost isn't much behind.

[Eskimo Brother]

With FW, I would definitely keep Bergeron.
I like PHs list, except I would keep Faulk over Kessel. Fills so many more categories and ensures you're not going in without a D.

[Flan]

you have collected some nice talent! in a 14 team league there must be some teams that are not nearly as deep that you can maybe tyr and do a 2 for 1 type deal with? Goalies is obviously your biggest need maybe explore a Crosby for Price deal, one bandaid boy for another?

[Sulla]

Ph's list and EB's amendment for me

[tandsmurphy]

Any other opinions?

[sharpp87]

C - Sidney Crosby, Evgeny Kuznetsov, Patrice Bergeron,
F - Patrick Kane, Johnny Gaudreau, Taylor Hall, Blake Wheeler
D - Justin Faulk, Shayne Gostisbehere
G - Tuukka Rask,

You should be able to redraft a Keith Yandle type of player. I keep Ghost since he is younger and producing almost the same as Yandle.
Its tought to let go Alex Galchenyuk but again you might be able to redraft him. Wheeler, Hall and Bergeron have to be keep before him.
I let go Vasilevskyi and Murray too. Its tought but with only 10 keepers per team, you might get a better, more establish goalie in draft or even take them again.
I think J. Faulk has to be keep since he should have a career season in CArolina, He is easily their no.1 PP guy and should get 50+ pts easily.
I dont keep Kessel because he might not start the year. Even if he does, I still prefer Wheeler, Hall, Bergeron...


Tought tought call but on some but this is my final 10.

[StuntMan12]

C Sidney Crosby
C Alex Galchenyuk
F Patrick Kane
F Johnny Gaudreau
F Taylor Hall
F Blake Wheeler
D Justin Faulk
D Shayne Gostisbehere
G Tuuka Rask
G Matt Murray

[tandsmurphy]

Here's what I did for keepers for what it's worth.
I was able to deal a few of the guys I wasn't going to keep for Seguin.
Thanks for the help!

Patrick Kane Chi - RW
Sidney Crosby Pit - C
Tyler Seguin Dal - C
Johnny Gaudreau Cgy - LW
Evgeny Kuznetsov Was - C
Patrice Bergeron Bos - C
Blake Wheeler Wpg - RW
Taylor Hall NJ - LW
Tuukka Rask Bos - G
Matt Murray Pit - G

[Sulla]

that's a nice ten to build around!

[Nehithaw]

You did excellent to acquire Seguin for non-keepers, very well done!

As for the keepers, there is not much different that I would have done. Faulk and Ghost are tough to let go, but you obviously know your league better than I do. Goodluck with your team going forward.

[tandsmurphy]

Thank you! I'm thinking I can get 1 back via draft... that's what I'm hoping anyways.

[junyab]

In a keep 10 I think you have to keep 2 goalies so I'd chose Vasil or Murray over Galchenyuk, twist my arm and I'd chose Vasil or Murray.

Sidney Crosby
Evgeny Kuznetsov
Patrice Bergeron
Patrick Kane
Johnny Gaudreau
Taylor Hall
Blake Wheeler
Phil Kessel
Tuukka Rask
Andrei Vasilevskiy

[tandsmurphy]

Was able to get Gostisbehere back in draft.