E.Lindholm + Vdunn - Nick Bjudstad + Ryan Strome

[Schaefer]

Which side between Bjuds + Strome or V.Dunn + ELindholm do you like most?

I think the strome side is better, but just trying to validate my view with the dobberites ;-)

Thanks!

[Eskimo Brother]

Assuming Strome is R. Strome from your sig?
And who is V. Dunn if you don't mind me asking?

[kevinsrangers]

I like the bjugstad and Ryan strome side better.but again, not sure who v.dunn is.

[Kofax]

I'm with the others. Bjugstad/Strome easily.

And yes, who is V. Dunn?

[Schaefer]

Yes Ryan and Vince Dunn: http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/stats/p...php?pid=170118

I don't know him.

[Eskimo Brother]

Not sure why the other owner thinks Dunn's name belongs with these other three, but it's not close IMO. Lindholm and Bjugstad are close, but a prospect none of us have really heard of in return for Strome doesn't make sense to me.

[Schaefer]

He must value Linholm a lot more than me.

[Eskimo Brother]

Agreed. Take a pass on the deal, and tell him if he wants Bjug/Strome, he can try another (better) offer.

[Noddes55]

Pass on this offer. Dunn at least 3-4 years away. And shouldn't even be considered being traded for strome

[Sulla]

I wouldn't trade Bjugstad for the package let alone add Strome...

[STONE.]

I think Dunn is totally ignored on this site, but his numbers are solid. He was a 2nd round pick known for offense. Other sites view him much more highly -- at times regarded as StL's best prospect.

In a year, I bet his name is a lot more prevalent here. He just hasn't cracked any Dobber lists

[Sulla]

But also St Louis is pretty deep to crack....

[STONE.]

But also St Louis is pretty deep to crack....

How well known was Parayko a year ago?

And if Shattenkirk gets moved, are they really that deep?

- - - Updated - - -

But I would still take the Strome / Bjugstad side

[Sulla]

But you also have Walman in the mix on d....

Parayko was on some radars (though granted not the way Werenski and Provorov are now)

[Ingolo]

How well known was Parayko a year ago?

And if Shattenkirk gets moved, are they really that deep?

- - - Updated - - -

But I would still take the Strome / Bjugstad side

Especially with the Weber PTO, I think St Louis is plenty deep, even if they move Shattenkirk. Definitely deep enough that they won't be rushing a 19 year old defensive prospect. Regardless of skill, I would expect Dunn to be at least 2 if not 3 years away from being ready for full-time.

That said, even if Dunn was ready to go today, I don't think he's worth Strome, and Lindholm is close to Bjugstad, but still a little lower for me. Unless the other GM is adding a top-tier prospect instead of Dunn, I would be walking away.