Best D on keeper league

[Vic]

Who should I get on a keeper league in pts only league?

Sergachev, Juolevi, Bean, Parayko, Girard, McAvoy, Trouba, Pulock, Theodore?

Thanks!

[PenguinHunter]

Points only league... I would take Parayko as he is proven.,

[Jouko-Pouko]

Parayko. After that, it's Sergachev, Pulock and Theodore in some order.

[Vic]

Points only league... I would take Parayko as he is proven.,

Only one year in NHL is it proven? Did Trouba could be a better option or did he will be only de defensive def?

[lucafen4]

Next year? Parayko or Theodore. There are still bodies in the way for Theodore to get max value next season, if he can get the ice time equivalent to Parayko, I'll take Theodore all day. Parayko is 2nd pair and is just waiting for Shattenkirk to move but should be 40ish points this year.

Third, I'd go Pulock, think he finally gets a look. I'm not sold on Trouba, just not.

Juolevi is the only one I can see getting ice time this season from the rest, but it's Vancouver, so limited return at best.

Beyond this year: Theodore - pedigree for offence is a step above.

[PenguinHunter]

Only one year in NHL is it proven? Did Trouba could be a better option or did he will be only de defensive def?

He has proven he can play in the NHL. lots of promising prospects never make it to the NHL, and when they do they don't produce as much as they were expected.

[tropheus_guy]

I have parayko (used one of my first waivers last year to steal him) in my multicat, but I would trade for Shea T as I think he is going to be a star with huge upside along the lines of ghost. I have doubts whether Colton will break out even though he will get more ice.

[Eskimo Brother]

Parayko. After that, it's Sergachev, Pulock and Theodore in some order.

I'm with Jouko on this as well.

[Rodgort]

Parayko and Pulock are you best bets. Especially with NYI wanting a big shot on their PP and at the same time keeping Boychuk for EV and SH ice time, not to mention he may be the cheaper of the two to acquire.

Then Theodore

Then Trouba

Then the drafted players, as who knows if they will turn out to be offense guys or two way/shut down guys as they become NHLers (or IF they become NHLers), in order (for best potential offense) I would go:
Bean
Sergachev
Juolevi
McAvoy
Girard

[Axeman33]

Pulock for me here in a points only format.

[lucafen4]

Pulock for me here in a points only format.

Even for 2016/17?

[Sulla]

Parayko. After that, it's Sergachev, Pulock and Theodore in some order.

another vote for this

[Axeman33]

Even for 2016/17?

It's a keeper league and the title on the thread says "Best D on keeper league". To me, the best D in a points only keeper league on that list that I like best is Pulock.

And for what it's worth, there's nothing to say that Pulock won't be just as good as Parayko in a points only league this upcoming season either. I don't see STL trading Shattenkirk any time soon.

[AngelicAssassin0]

Can't go wrong with Pulock or Theodore IMO, in that order.

[kevinsrangers]

Parayko then theodore for me.