Hemsky vs. Marleau vs. Michalek vs Gaborik (

[leafs_1979]

So I\'m racking my brain trying to figure out who\'ll perform better this year.

this is a keeper pool as well but I\'ve got a pretty solid list of keepers ahead of these guys so unless they set the world on fire I won\'t be keeping them.

what do you think? points are based on G, A, PP points, and +/-.

for the record I\'m leaning

Gaborik (40,40,25,15) = 120
Michalek (30,35,25,10) = 100
Hemsky (20,60,30,-10) = 100 --> greatest chance to go nuts
Marleau (25,45,25,-5) = 90 --> can he bounce back better then this?

also.. wondering where cheechoo would fit given the type of years both Michalek and Marleau could have... would like your opinions.


thanks for your help.

[Shoeless]

I think you list probably would look like this once the season is done.

Gabbie
Hemsky
Michalek
Cheechoo
Marleau

Give them whatever points you want.

If you have keepers better than Gabbie and Hemsky - you have one heck of a team.

[leafs_1979]

I\'ve got
Crosby
Malkin
E. Staal
Pronger
Price
Giguere

huge staal fan... he\'s the only one I see dropping for Hemmer or Gabbie.

thanks for your input

[Shoeless]

Well now I understand your dilemma - that decision is pure torture. I assume positions don\'t factor in here.

[shallowfrozenwater]

i would NOT drop Eric Staal in a keeper for either Hemsky or Gaborik

[Zorro]

I\'d drop Pronger before Staal for Gaborik.

[JAC123]

I\'m with Zorro on this one,
Drop Pronger for Gaborik.
I think it is a no brainer.
Take the points, hope he is healthy and run

[leafs_1979]

positions don\'t matter for my pool

thanks for your help

[Shao]

No brainer.

Shoeless has it right.

[Garbage Goal]

Agree on dropping pronger for Gabby.

Shao...I\'ve seen the avatar 100+ times and every time is as good as the first. Who is she? I love her!

[Garbage Goal]

never mind i found her and the full video is hilarious hahaha

[Shao]

I actually don\'t know, maybe you could fill me in?

[Garbage Goal]

Yeah her name is Margaret Nolan...late 60\'s mid-70\'s actress.