Thoughts on trade proposal

[rangerfan2430]

For league in my signature. I am talking to the Varlamov owner and I sent him an offer of my Zuccarello, Jagr, and Desharnais for his Kessel and Varlamov. Is this a fair proposal? League details in my signature. Kessel was his keeper and he drafter Varlamov in the first round (really 7th round because we keep 6 players)

[als_revenge]

I suppose Zucc for Kessel is ok, but that's really selling low / buying high from his perspective.
Jagr and Descharnais don't really excite me. Who are his other goalies? If he took Varly in the first round, then it sounds like this deal will leave him really light in goal.

[rangerfan2430]

He has Varly, Holtby, Elliot, Mrazek, and Condon

[Axeman33]

What we think is fair may differ greatly what he thinks is fair.

Personally I don't have an issue with the offer but if you are taking a goalie from him and not sending one back my first train of thought is what the rest of his roster looks like.

[Nikerato]

If I were him, that's the kind of offer I wouldn't even reply to. Zucc isn't a keeper for anybody in any keep 6 league.

[rangerfan2430]

What we think is fair may differ greatly what he thinks is fair.

Personally I don't have an issue with the offer but if you are taking a goalie from him and not sending one back my first train of thought is what the rest of his roster looks like.

I asked the guy if he wanted a goalie coming back and he said no. He said he wants to get rid of a goalie

[Axeman33]

I asked the guy if he wanted a goalie coming back and he said no. He said he wants to get rid of a goalie

Interesting. Send the offer and see what he says.

[rangerfan2430]

Interesting. Send the offer and see what he says.

Ya, I sent the offer and will post what he says. I hope he accepts it but if he rejects it, maybe I'll swap Zuccarello for Duchene

[Bra]

I don't get the love for Kessel. He's been adequate for the last two years. He peaked in Boston.

Why do you want a player who will disappoint you and a goaltender on a terrible team?

You'll regret trading away Duchene.

[Axeman33]

I don't get the love for Kessel. He's been adequate for the last two years. He peaked in Boston.

Why do you want a player who will disappoint you and a goaltender on a terrible team?

You'll regret trading away Duchene.

Peaked in Boston??

His best year in Boston - 70GP 36G 60 pts.

His best year in Toronto - 82GP 37G 82 pts.

Theres no arguing last year was tough for Phil but the three years prior to that he was a PPG player, and those don't come around often.

[havanablast21]

Peaked in Boston??

His best year in Boston - 70GP 36G 60 pts.

His best year in Toronto - 82GP 37G 82 pts.

Theres no arguing last year was tough for Phil but the three years prior to that he was a PPG player, and those don't come around often.

Gotta hope he meant to say "Peaked in Toronto". Let's fans can only hope!