T. Hall vs J. Benn

[gabrielbeau]

Who would you rather have in a points only keeper league Hall or Benn? For me it'd be Hall, I'm not sure how big is the difference.

[havanablast21]

Agree. hall. Tough to see at the moment but I beleive he comes out ahead of Benn in the long term.

[Slug]

Hall for me. Give me the player who is 2 years younger and has proven he can score at better than a ppg clip. An argument could be made for Benn because Hall is so injury prone but Benn himself is no ironman.

[kevinsrangers]

Points only I'd take hall all day long.

[blayze]

I'll take Benn - every bit as good as Hall without the glass vagina.

[Canucks_fan18]

Im with Blayze I like the guarrentee. However if I only had one stud to choose from and the rest of my squad was crap I would swing for the fences with Hall who I see has a slightly higher upside but a hell of a lot more risk.

[havanablast21]

I'll take Benn - every bit as good as Hall without the glass vagina.

Im with Blayze I like the guarrentee. However if I only had one stud to choose from and the rest of my squad was crap I would swing for the fences with Hall who I see has a slightly higher upside but a hell of a lot more risk.

With all due respect... "Without the glass vagina" and "sure thing" comments... In 5 full seasons, not including this one... Benn has managed a full 82 game season once.

I don't call that the pillar of health alternative nor a "sure thing"! Lol

I still take Hall.

[JimmyCanuck]

Hall!

[fungchen3]

Jamie Benn. I'm sorry, I don't trust the Oilers and I don't trust Hall with his reckless style. While I think there will be years Hall puts it all together, stays healthy, and out-points Benn by 5-7 points, I'll take the guy with PPG+ talent and who is fortunate enough to play with Tylers Seguin each night. I think Benn is a steady 80-85 point player from here on out, with potential to do more - just think if / when he, Seguin and Nichushkin are put together and cooking.

[sportznutt]

Benn.....plus, Hall won't reach his potential for another few years, and Benn/Seguin are deadly.

[blayze]

Two words: BennGuin... well actually that's one word.

[VincentVega]

Jamie Benn. I'm sorry, I don't trust the Oilers and I don't trust Hall with his reckless style. While I think there will be years Hall puts it all together, stays healthy, and out-points Benn by 5-7 points, I'll take the guy with PPG+ talent and who is fortunate enough to play with Tylers Seguin each night. I think Benn is a steady 80-85 point player from here on out, with potential to do more - just think if / when he, Seguin and Nichushkin are put together and cooking.

This pretty much sums up my thoughts too.

[havanablast21]

Two words: BennGuin... well actually that's one word.

Not to be confused with "Bengay". Even the Ultra Strength.

[Bomm Bastic]

I agree w/fungchen insofar as Hall's injuries being a major concern.

BUT

If we see Hall w/McDavid that could change mind.

[ds760]

This isn't even close. How vcan anyone suggest Hall of Benn. Just look at the numbers and missed games. Not to mention Eakins called Hall a cancer in the locker room. Since Seguin went down this guy has taken it to another level. When has Hall ever done that?