I am not convinced you win either trade. Nor does the other GM. Seems a wash either way. All the guys involved play top line minutes, top PP minutes, earn similar numbers of PIM, get similar SOG. My only tipping point may be that both Seguin and Giroux are currently on weaker teams than Kane, but over time that could level out.
If you want to shake things up for the sake of shaking things up and your love for Kane, logic dictates that Giroux is an elite player and that you gotta let Seguin go.
20-team, points only. G: 2-W, 4-SO.
Top 9F, 4D & 1G . Keep 15, Carry 20
F: Stamkos, MacKinnon, Stepan, Scheifele, Nichushkin, Marner, McCann, J.T. Miller, Simmonds, A. Lee, Hornqvist
D: Ekblad, Barrie, Nurse, DeAngelo, Severson, Orlov
G: F. Andersen, Gibson, Vasilevskiy
Let The Right Muzzin; RHRS
C:Bergeron, Huberdeau, Vermette, Z. Smith
LW: Landeskog, Toffoli, Pouliot, Hartnell
RW: Tarasenko, Seguin, Saad, Trochek
D: Shattenkirk, Muzzin, Nurse, Holden, Spurgeon
G: Bishop, Talbot
Bench: Nilsson, Hammond, Hamonic, Korpisalo, K. miller, Killorn