Loui Eriksson or Yakupov

[abt1n]

12 team points only keeper league, with locked rosters till december.
So I have two trade offers

A concussed Loui Eriksson (on the guy's roster, so he has to trade him to get him off his active roster) for Hudler and a second round pick (if loui plays more than 55 games this season)

or
Yakupov for Hudler and a second round

I'm not really sold on Yak, im expecting a big sophmore slump, but he is not concussed.

Loui is hearty, hasn't really missed too many games, so he should bounce back fine.

[Shift Disturber]

I like how you made the pick conditional upon the number of games Eriksson plays, but I don't see him as an upgrade over Hudler in a points-only league especially on a deep Boston squad. So, why make the deal, and why throw in a pick on top of that?

If you can afford the roster spot, then take the Yak deal. Who knows what he'll do this year, but I like him in a keeper league.

[abt1n]

I figure that Eriksson is a reliable 70pt player whereas Hudler has never hit 60 before, but is having a great start.

I like how you made the pick conditional upon the number of games Eriksson plays, but I don't see him as an upgrade over Hudler in a points-only league especially on a deep Boston squad. So, why make the deal, and why throw in a pick on top of that?

If you can afford the roster spot, then take the Yak deal. Who knows what he'll do this year, but I like him in a keeper league.

[The Bottlenecker]

Keep Hudler. Eriksson is out and you never know how long when it comes to head injuries, and Yak is sucking on the "sophomore sucks" juice. He will pull it together eventually, but not soon enough to out point Hudler this year. And then he wants picks too. Nope, neither deal is in your best interest.

[The Hockey Hitman]

Are my eyes deceiving me?! You can get Yakupov for Hudler and a 2nd round pick? Talk about a steal. I'd take Yakupov and run.

[lucifer316]

depending on the number of keepers i think the Yak deal is a good one maybe even a great one