Best options for future/present

[frankiejay]

16 team keeper league with this roster, standard stats.

C: Stamkos, Koivu
LW: JvR, Landeskog
RW: Voracek, Carter
D: Yandle, Voynov
G: Holtby

I figure I have three options: vets, youngens or a 2nd goalie (we only keep one). Which player would you prefer to draft in the first round?

Vets: Justin Williams, Iginla, Phaneuf
Youngens: Atkinson, Silfverberg, Bennett
A 2nd goalie: Schneider, Dubnyk, Nabokov

[junyab]

I'd do Dubnyk...I expect big things from him (and Edmonton) this year.

[dmvincent]

Schneider would be my choice.

[The Hockey Hitman]

Schneider would be my choice.

Considering it's a 16 team league, I feel you'd be best served by adding a goaltender...and I agree with dmvincent, take Schneider. He's looked great in New Jersey so far and is the most talented goalie available.

[als_revenge]

Considering it's a 16 team league, I feel you'd be best served by adding a goaltender...and I agree with dmvincent, take Schneider. He's looked great in New Jersey so far and is the most talented goalie available.

He can keep one goalie at the end of the year. Unless you think Schneider is a better option than Holtby going forward, I don't see the point in using his first round pick on him. NJ looks like there are a mess this year.