need a little advice

[Mooseknuckles_2.1]

hey guys, i'm in a 10 team keeper league with a roster of 30 keep 15

I finished 1st last year but by a hair! I think by 3 points


i originally offered another manager the following:
My Benn and Faulk for his Keith and Stepan

My Defence is a little weak right now My current keepers are only Letang and Shattenkirk

He countered with :
My St. Louis and Faulk for Keith and Stepan

I delcined and he re-countered @:
My Faulk and Bäckström for Keith and Stepan

Is this enough return?

18 forwards, 8 defence and 4 goalies. The 13 forwards, 5 defence, and 2 goalies with the highest point total

Scoring Cats: Skaters g,a = 1 ea, PPP = .5 ea, SHP = 2
Goalies W=2, SO=3, A = 1 ea, PPP = .5 ea, SHP = 2

my current Roster (Green = Current Keepers):
Evgeni Nabokov (nyi) G
Sergei Bobrovsky (cls) GViktor Fasth (anh) G
Craig Anderson (ott) G
Kris Letang (pit) D
Francois Beauchemin (anh) D
Kevin Shattenkirk (stl) D
Fedor Tyutin (cls) D
Justin Faulk (car) D
Dennis Seidenberg (bos) D
Kevin Bieksa (van) D
David Rundblad (pho) D
Martin St. Louis (tb)
Sidney Crosby (pit)
Phil Kessel (tor)
Nicklas Backstrom (was)
Joe Thornton (sj)
Nazem Kadri (tor) James Neal (pit)
Jiri Tlusty (car)
Brad Boyes (nyi)
Cody Hodgson (buf)
Jamie Benn (dal)
James Van Riemsdyk (tor)
Daniel Alfredsson (ott)
Saku Koivu (anh)
Ryane Clowe (nyr)
Drew Stafford (buf)
Ryan Kesler (van) Mikael Granlund (min)

Green are my current keepers:

[mooseknuckles]

also redundant... hopefully a Mod can delete this...sorry for the trouble guys!

[swampmule]

My gut says this isn't enough return. Backsdtrom has potential for more points than Stepan and I don't think Keith's points can close the gap.