Jonas Brodin or Justin Schultz

[AlexR]

In the game I played almost everything count. Almost all the stats are use to give the players a rating in different skills.

If you would have to choose between Schultz or Brodin at the next draft you would you choose.

[Mattp913]

This is so so far from being remotely close. Schultz is better than like 5 Brodin's.

[Leafer]

Schultz gets my vote, & probs 100% of the votes!

[AlexR]

This is so so far from being remotely close. Schultz is better than like 5 Brodin's.

In all aspect of the game or just for point production?

[Call of Doughty]

Brodin, if you want to lose.

[VincentVega]

Brodin is a very good defenseman but he is one of those players who is much better in real life than fantasy. In real life, Brodin may end up the better. But in fanasy, it's not close at all. As all posts already say, Schults is your man.

[Call of Doughty]

In all aspect of the game or just for point production?

Schultz: goals, assists, +/-, sog, time on ice

probably close on hits

Brodin might win blocks and take a ways. Brodin is likely the better defensive defenceman, but Schultz is pure offensive and is the main cat in Oil land. Brodin has some guy called Suter in his way.

[AlexR]

edit: I will rephrase my question in the pool. Mod feel free to close this tread.

[Call of Doughty]

last season Brodin had more time on ice than Schultz, not by much but still. And Schultz was pretty bad in +/-.

Those were my predictions for this year. I didn't look up last years. I'd expect his time on ice to increase as will his defensive awareness as he plays through season 2.But yeah, he was a little iffy in his own end.

[AlexR]

I have refine my question concerning Brodin and Schultz.

[Lindenrulz]

Points Only: Schultz
Multi Cat: Brodin

[Call of Doughty]

I have refine my question concerning Brodin and Schultz.

Alex, you haven't really even given us a question here!?! Please include your league's categories with your threads.

Does your question remain, who's better? who would you take?

Again, more info needed. I'm confused.

[AlexR]

Alex, you haven't really even given us a question here!?! Please include your league's categories with your threads.

Does your question remain, who's better? who would you take?

Again, more info needed. I'm confused.

I think you replied before the poll was made.

[Call of Doughty]

I think you replied before the poll was made.

Sorry my bad. But get your signature updated and league peripherals in place.

I feel both #1 and #2 are true, so that's why we need your league's setup to see where to place our votes.

[Lindenrulz]

Points Only: Scultz
Multi Cat: Brodin

These two players have different skill sets. One is only better than the other in the context of a specific fantasy format. They both have as much potential to do well in thier respective fantasy format.