I don't know what to do..

[Dreamer]

His
Lecavalier
Rick Nash

My

Brad Richards
Alex Galchenyuk
First round pick but it's not an early pick...it's like 10th to 12th overall


Point only league

[dejeanneret]

I'd not do that deal.

It's closer if you are not giving up a draft pick, but I'd still likely sit tight. In a points only Nash loses a considerable amount of his value. I'm also in the camp that thinks Richards can bounce back this season under AV and with some proper training in the offseason, and I think Galchenyuk will become a pretty special player too.

[jcairns]

If you are rebuilding, don't take it and try to get rid of just Richards for someone younger as he is on a fast downhill slide in my opinion.

If you are a contender, take it and run. Nash will outproduce Galenchyuk and Richards this year, and Lecavalier will as well (assuming he stays healthy).

The only problem is I don't have any idea about what a 10th round pick would land in your league.

[HockeyProphet]

Without more information, what sort of players are available 10th overall, how many keepers, etc.

I would do that deal.

[Mattp913]

Nash is by far the best player in the deal right now so if you are trying to win this year it's not really a bad deal. Also, I prefer Lecavalier to Richards. Having said that, Galchenyuk is much younger and has the potential to be the best player in the deal several years down the road so it's tough. I don't know that it's worth giving up on such a young stud like Galchenyuk unless you are very confident that adding Nash and Lecavalier would help you win it all this season. I'd probably advise not to do it, but it's definitely close depending on your needs.

[Pengwin7]

I think Nash will score 5pts more than B.Richards.
I think Lecavalier will outscore Galchenyuk over the next two years.

B.Richards/Galchenyuk possibly starts to win this trade in year 3 and on.

Nash/Lecavalier for me.
I'm not waiting for Gally.

[Dreamer]

12 team pool
Points only

Thedeal is done.

12 Forwards count
5 Defenses count
2 Goalies count

This is my team:

Forwards:
Evgeni Malkin
Vincent Lecavalier
Jordan Eberle
Alexander Semin
Mikko Koivu
Rick Nash
Jonathan Huberdeau
Mikhael Grigorenko
Mackinnon (Draft)
Sean Couturier
Gustav Nyquist
Filip Forsberg
Evgeny Kuznetsov
Carl Söderberg


Defenses:
Tobias Enstrom
Drew Doughty
John Carlson
Alex Pietrangelo
Dougie Hamilton
Adam Larsson
Brendan Smith
Tom Gilbert (Dump)

Goalies:
Jonathan Quick
Tuukka Rask
Martin Brodeur
John Gibson

I have the first overall pick so I will dump Tom Gilbert to draft Mackinnon

[prkal8r]

I think Gally is still a few years away from being a quality producer... good deal for you.