Schneider Trade...yay or nay?

[TheCamelToews]

This one makes me nervous....

I trade Schneider, Skinner, AP, fourth overall

For

Bishop, Seguin, Hamilton, and second overall

League below

Questions....can Miller and Rinne keep my team afloat? Only two goalies count..does Nashville drafting Jones help Rinne long term?

Skinner or Seguin? Getting less confident in Skinners ability to stay healthy..

And of course how does everyone feel about Schneider in NJ?

And last....I am 95% sure that third overall next year is taking Jones, meaning I'll take Barkov, giving me a pretty bad ass tag team of him and Hubs. Is Drouin worth it?

Seems kind of steep to me, but I think Seguin breaks out and Skinner gets a couple other concussions next year.

Let me know your thoughts!

[TheCamelToews]

Minor update....

I would recieve Varlamov instead of Bishop in this one.....

[Atomic Wedgy]

I wouldn't be making that deal. No way.

Schneider >>> Bishop
Schneider > Valramov
Skinner = Seguin
AP >> Hamilton
2nd overall is marginally worse than 4th overall

Even if the deal is for Valamov, I still wouldn't do it.

[kenzle1r]

I agree. Drop AP and Hamilton and I think you have a nice balanced deal. Hamilton may one day be as good as AP (doubt it but it could happen) but he clearly no where near AP.

[sparrowtrini]

horrible trade anyway you look at it.

[TheCamelToews]

thanks guys...

Its moments like this where its nice to have a place to confirm "you would be crazy to" moments.

The only person I really really want on my team is Drouin, and even if it goes Mackinnon, Drouin, Barkov, id be happy to stuff Jones on my bench long term.

That was a close one, thanks again!

[Zorro]

I ouldn't do this deal.. You are giving up way too much to get 2nd overall.. Be happy you are in the top 4 and keep Schneider, Skinner, and AP..

Try and offer Skinner and 4th overall for Seguin and 2nd overall..

[JagrBomb]

almost as bad as trading schneider for 9th overall

[mister_mcgoo]

almost as bad as trading schneider for 9th overall

zingggggg!

[3rtpaper]

Going to agree with everyone here..

I wouldn't trade for 2 Boston players.. that team is all defense and it limits offensive production. Seguin has a lot more skill and health than Skinner but Seguin offense won't be fully utilized playing with Boston. With Boston's GM saying Seguin needs to be more "professional" - I really read that as "Seguin needs to focus on and play Boston's system". Yeah it might be training and focus related but I really feel like this is going to be a square peg and round hole kind of a thing. I didn't like his outlook prior to these comments and I like Seguin's outlook even less now.