If this is about that league we conversed about earlier then it's a good deal. You can get some pretty good players with those two picks. As you mentioned, Semin is a non-factor for you since he was a non-keeper anyhow. Tavares is the best player in the deal and Kane is close in value. So it pretty much amounts to a 1st+2nd for Neal from your standpoint. I'd do it. It'd be nice to know who you'll be able to draft at those spots though.