Id be giving up Charlie Coyle for Mcdonagh, I have loads of forward depth with the likes of Benn, Stamkos, Couture, Wheeler, Neal and Tarasenko to name a few. Defence is a concern with Pieterangelo, Chara, Orlov, Tyutin, Carle and Ference with depth guys coming in from the minors. Its a SIM league where nhl stats are based on player re rates. Just looking for opinions on this deal, thanks guys.