A few things to address here. I wasn't impressed with Nyquist in the game last night in my opinion, he made a few good plays and his goal. He had a one on one with a defenseman and to me, it looked like he didn't know what to do and wasnt decisive. It made the play look amateur to me.
Applecutter, is a different situation. He is a grind it out player and if we have learned anything from the Wings, they love those type of players on the top line. How long did Holmstrom stay on the top line and produce at a low level? He got some goal important goals sure and he was the tip in and redirection master but I don't seem him having anymore talent than Abdelkader.
Brunner was already paired up with Zetterberg in the Swedish league(where ever they were playing) and you don't really need to have another trial period for a guy already producing on a line with the team captain. I'm sure Zetts had Brunner locked up before they even started the season.
DId Tatar look good, absolutely. Do I think he should stay with the team and leave Nyquist down? For sure. Do I trust Red Wings Management of players. Shit yea. My opinion means nothing except the Wings have proven they handle players well.