My hall for Malkin

[The Mac]

should i take the risk?

or look at my roster who would u offer?

[T.Melnychuk19]

I would take that trade not look back. Your getting a proven 100+ point scorer.

[habs7079]

If you have any shot of getting Malkin, you have to do it right away and be willing to move any of your forwards outside of Crosby and Stamkos to get him. He's been cleared for contact so whatever window there might be will be closed soon.

[The Mac]

but its concussion...scary deal imo lol

[rougie]

but its concussion...scary deal imo lol

He should be returning within a week or so.
Geno >>> Hall

[The Guvnah]

If you have any shot of getting Malkin, you have to do it right away and be willing to move any of your forwards outside of Crosby and Stamkos to get him. He's been cleared for contact so whatever window there might be will be closed soon.

This. If there's any possibility of you obtaining Malkin for Hall or nearly ANY combination of your other players outside of Stamkos & Crosby, throw a damn bowling ball at that 'Accept' button!

[bondon]

What in the ****!?

LOL. Malkin. Hall is injured too right now...I can only assume you're OFFERING this because i don't see how an owner would be stupid enough to offer this to you.

[The Mac]

offered to me after i denied zetterberg

[bondon]

Man seriously take it and run.

Not to mention you're far more stacked on the LW than at RW. I get that there is the concussion scare with Malkin and all but when he's in the lineup he's definitely a couple tiers above Hall. As I mentioned already Hall is also dealing with injuries right now. Some actually thought that Hall was having issues before the game that it was injured. (By the way, I own Hall in my one-year and i'd deal him for Malkin in a heartbeat)

I can't believe I'm still trying to find ways to justify this!

[The Mac]

gawd everyone here says yes..everywhere else says no

[bondon]

gawd everyone here says yes..everywhere else says no

I'd really like to hear "everywhere else's" counterpoints to the points I just made in my last post.

Other than "But it's a concussion"

[The Mac]

mainly concussions LOL...and the risk of reinjury

Damn me being a oiler fan..i traded eberle for no problem why not hall lol

[Chuk]

gawd everyone here says yes..everywhere else says no

Me thinks someone has been hanging out with Eklund, on ESPN or HFBOARDS.

Honestly, when it comes to Malkin (Crosby, Stamkos) Unless he is officially gone for the season, he still has a shot at outscoring whoever you trade for him.

I do understand the concern about concussions but in a situation where he is skating and talking about coming back, rest assured the risk is minimal.

Besides he was injured on a fluke play that can happen to anyone any night. AND.. he still might play more games than Hall with or without a concussion.

[The Mac]

nah just friends, hockey group on fb..**** it imma do the deal

[The Guvnah]

nah just friends, hockey group on fb..**** it imma do the deal

Please do. Unless Malkin is out for the rest of the season, this is a no-brainer. Hall has had injury problems too, and has come nowhere near the level of production Malkin has shown himself capable of. Do it. DO IT!!!