Better package for E. Staal?

[wizworm]

Contemplating two seperate deals that involve E. Staal... which one do you think is better? Team and scoring are in my sig.

TRADE 1
E. Staal
H. Sedin
Varlamov
for
(Roster drops)
Hueberdeau
Markstrom
Shultz
2nd round prospect pick (1st if he wins the leauge... currently in 2nd overall)

TRADE 2
E. Staal
for
Hopkins
B. Smith
2nd round prospect pick

Either way, if I move Staal I activate Turris to my roster and he's one of my 9 protected players going forward.

[lucifer316]

neither deal

[metaldude26]

neither deal

Agreed, although the second deal is technically the better of the two.

[lucifer316]

Agreed, although the second deal is technically the better of the two.

you have me there

[ryanreynolds99]

both are not great deals