Neal+ for Perry+

[chowder]

1 year H2H. This was offered to me...who wins?

G, A, +/-, PPP, SOG, HIT, BLK

Jeff Carter
James Neal
Mike Green

for

Corey Perry
Milan Lucic
Justin Schultz

[jimc21]

Easy win for the Perry side. Carter sucks, Green is always hurt and is not playing like Green, and Neal is a fantasy monster. But he's all alone on that side of the trade.

Perry is not the Perry of a couple years ago, but he's not going to hurt you when you count hits and blocks. Lucic is a beast. And I expect Schultz will come alive, play a ton more games than Green, and probably outpoint him.

But honestly, I would have a hard time trading Neal. He is a heavyweight fantasy player.

[msb]

I would side with Neal, Carter and Green.

Carter does not suck... former 30 goal scorer, finding his legs this year with 8 goals. Subjectively, I don't think Perry will attain his previous elite status, however he still he is a great player. Just my 2 cents.

[PatInTheHat]

It's close but i'd give the slight edge to Perry side. I don't have a lot of faith in Green doing much this season and I think Schultz will only improve from here out. It really comes down to how much of a difference you think there will be between Neal and Perry. You know exactly what Neal's numbers will look like at seasons end and even a worst case scenario of Perry repeating last year this deal still seems OK.

Neal > Perry
Carter < Lucic
Green < Schultz