Heatley Huberdeau or Duchene Ribeiro?

[BogosianLandeskog]

i have a tentative deal in place , id get his Duchene Ribeiro and hed get my Heatley Huberdeau....now is this worth doing?

[Puppage]

Definitely not. Heatley is better this year than Duchene or Ribeiro. Heatley's play seems to be rejuvenated alongside Koivu and Parise. On the flip side, the Capitals offense does not seem to have the fire power it once had, so I cannot see Ribeiro being better than Heatley this year. Duchene seems to be a wild card, but I still think Heatley will be better than him this year.

And for the future, I would rather have Huberdeau than Duchene. From what I have seen of Huberdeau he plays a complete and consistent game which bodes well for the future. Again, I am not entirely sold on Duchene. He seems to yo-yo from stud to ghost, and I would rather have some consistent in my fantasy line up then taking a chance on a guy who might not score for a week.

[cdubb]

Agree with Puppage.

It's a goal heavy league. Despite my hating Heatley (disgruntled Sens fan) Parise is rejuvenating him.

Plus I feel Hubs better potential than Duchene,

[Essej]

I'd rather have Duchene and Ribiero, together they should combine for a greater total of points than Heatley and Huberdeau. I'd also have Duchene over Huberdeau for the long haul, as Duchene is more of a proven commodity, and has excellent potential as well.

[Bubba55]

I like the Heatley/Huberdeau side here. Lets call Hubs and Duchene a wash here, no one knows what will happen, both are good players and time will tell. With Hubs start though, I am leaning that way. What we do know is what to expect from Heately and Ribeiro. Heatley has struggled a bit of late but Ribeiro has not exactly threatened the PPG mark that both these guys have achieved and are capable of. This is all about your scoring cats. Heatley is a goal scorer. Ribeiro is a playmaker. Case closed. 2 pts for goals? Your giving up too much. I don't do this deal.

[Pengwin7]

Heatley/Huberdeau is better side.

[MarmotKing]

I would keep Heatley and Huberdeau if it was me.