Who to pick and who to leave?

[theslymonkey]

League and team details in my signature.

I have picks 3 and 5 in the draft tonight. I want to make sure I take the best two options and then hope that some steals fall to my three second round picks at 11 and 12. I plan on using my last second rounder (19) to pick up a second goalie because there are enough options available that I dont need to rush.

Here are my top selections for 3 and 5. None of them are really able to displace my current keepers, so I am looking to pick for the win this year. Who are the top five or six and what order should they be picked.

Iginla
Koivu
Heatley
Benn
Selanne
Semin
Ribeiro
J.Staal
Byfuglien
Pietrangelo
Chara

***EDIT***
And is there any value of drafting Yakupov, Grandlund, Tarasenko, or Huberdeau early?

[Rocky71]

League and team details in my signature.

I have picks 3 and 5 in the draft tonight. I want to make sure I take the best two options and then hope that some steals fall to my three second round picks at 11 and 12. I plan on using my last second rounder (19) to pick up a second goalie because there are enough options available that I dont need to rush.

Here are my top selections for 3 and 5. None of them are really able to displace my current keepers, so I am looking to pick for the win this year. Who are the top five or six and what order should they be picked.

Iginla
Koivu
Heatley
Benn
Selanne
Semin
Ribeiro
J.Staal
Byfuglien
Pietrangelo
Chara

Here is how I would rank them;

Benn
Koivu
Iginla
J.Staal
Heatley
Selanne
Semin
Ribeiro


Pietrangelo
Chara
Byfuglien

[MikeTSchmidt]

Here's my top six:

Byfuglien -- Only d-man with 50-plus points in each of past two seasons.
Benn -- Just entering his prime and best scorer on this list.
J. Staal -- Should excel in more prominent role.
Pietrangelo -- Great player, but I'm not as high on him as others are for fantasy.
Chara -- So, so solid.
Koivu -- Only thing I don't like is he's missed 38 games over past two years.
Iginla -- A shadow of his former self, but that's still pretty good.

[theslymonkey]

Here is how I would rank them;

Benn
Koivu
Iginla
J.Staal
Heatley
Selanne
Semin
Ribeiro


Pietrangelo
Chara
Byfuglien

I appreciate the help, but I'm wrestling where the D fit in with forwards.