Perry + OEL for Sharp + Goli + Wideman ***Deal Amended
Hey Guys,
Looking for help on an offer. He really wants Perry and OEL, he has sent Sharp, Goligoski and Wideman. I don't think this is enough as I am giving up the two best players IMO.
With Subban not signed and Elliott not playing, I am now relying on an unsigned Subban and Robidas. I could use the D help but is this worth it.
He does have Giroux so not sure if substituting Giroux for Sharp would be fair. I think that OEL's upside IMO is worth Goli and Wideman.
Thoughts?
Last edited by The Wrong Marine; January 19, 2013 at 10:05 PM. Reason: Trade Changed
14 Team Keeper League
Keep 15
Start 9F 5D 1G
G A PIM GWG W SO OTL
Starters
F: Pastrnak, Kaprizov, Lafrenniere, Pettersson, Raymond, Byfield, Rossi, Hayton, Arvidsson
D: Seider, Hanifin, Drysdale, Boqvist, Shultz
G: Demko
Bench:
F: Pelletier, Noesen
D: Lundkvist, Hutson, Nikishin, Addison, Spence, York, Zamula
G: Levi, Wolf
IR: Fantilli, Sergachev
Originally Posted by The Wrong Marine
I would keep what you have. It is NOT worth it. And I definitely see him NOT parting with Giroux for those players. I don't think you have a match either way. If you keep forcing it, one of you will end up being a BIG loser. Sometimes the best deal is NO DEAL.
League:Fantrax 18 Team Dynasty, H2H (4C, 8W, 6D, 1G)
Cats:G, A, GWG, PPP, SHP, SOG, H+B, FOW, S, SV%, W, GAA
C: Backstrom,Giroux,MacKinnon,Seguin
W: D.Brown,Hartnell,Hossa,P.Kane
Kesler,Marleau,Perron,Zibanejad
D: Boyle,Del Zotto,Doughty,D.Hamilton,Hedman,Markov
G: Rinne
Bench: Braun,Comeau, Demers,DeHaan,Polak,Stempniak,Wingels --Fleury
That offer is AWFUL. You have the 2 best players in that deal by a long shot. Obviously, adding Giroux makes it a lot better, but, your trade partner probably doesn't want to go there. With PIMs being part of your stats, Perry should light it up this year.
Good Luck!
12 -Team Yahoo, Points Pool, Keeper (Since 1995): G(1), A(1), PPG(1), SHG(1) GWG(1), W(2), SHO(3). Protect 13 each season.
C (4): Hayes, Bonino, White, Bozak
LW (4): Aho, Huberdeau, K Connor, Gourde
RW (4): Perry, Boeser, Tuch, Zucker
F (1):Labanc
D (4): Barrie, Theodore, Faulk, Shattenkirk
G (1): Lehner
Bench: (C) Kerfoot, (RW) Silfverberg, (LW) Bertuzzi (D) Q Hughes, R Murray, D'Angelo (G) Demko, Markstrom,
Perfect answers...exactly my train of thought. In a win now mode I think the Giroux, Goli and Wideman offer is pretty decent return but other than that I don't see a deal being reached...thanks for the reiteration.
Rep
14 Team Keeper League
Keep 15
Start 9F 5D 1G
G A PIM GWG W SO OTL
Starters
F: Pastrnak, Kaprizov, Lafrenniere, Pettersson, Raymond, Byfield, Rossi, Hayton, Arvidsson
D: Seider, Hanifin, Drysdale, Boqvist, Shultz
G: Demko
Bench:
F: Pelletier, Noesen
D: Lundkvist, Hutson, Nikishin, Addison, Spence, York, Zamula
G: Levi, Wolf
IR: Fantilli, Sergachev
He changed the deal to:
Sharp, Goligoski and Kaberle for my Zajac and OEL
I think Goli and OEL are close fantasy wise and Sharp is a pretty good upgrade over Zajac.
Am I crazy to not accept this or am I overvaluing OEL that much?
14 Team Keeper League
Keep 15
Start 9F 5D 1G
G A PIM GWG W SO OTL
Starters
F: Pastrnak, Kaprizov, Lafrenniere, Pettersson, Raymond, Byfield, Rossi, Hayton, Arvidsson
D: Seider, Hanifin, Drysdale, Boqvist, Shultz
G: Demko
Bench:
F: Pelletier, Noesen
D: Lundkvist, Hutson, Nikishin, Addison, Spence, York, Zamula
G: Levi, Wolf
IR: Fantilli, Sergachev
I wonder how much OEL will be limited as long as Yandle is still there. Being points only (pretty much) I would think Goligoski is a good replacement. I could even see Goligoski outpoint OEL in the short term. Long-term who knows, but Goligoski is the #1 D in Dallas so if he's a consistent 40+ producer then I wouldn't complain. Sharp over Zajac is a solid upgrade as well.
Personally, I would tell him to remove Kaberle as you'd have to drop someone unnecessarily and just make it: Sharp/Goligoski for Zajac/OEL. But you know how much you like OEL so up to you - just trying to give an unbiased opinion.
Thanks Horrorfan...rep to all so far. Was thinking Kaberle could fill the Subban spot until/if he signs
Any other thoughts on this?
14 Team Keeper League
Keep 15
Start 9F 5D 1G
G A PIM GWG W SO OTL
Starters
F: Pastrnak, Kaprizov, Lafrenniere, Pettersson, Raymond, Byfield, Rossi, Hayton, Arvidsson
D: Seider, Hanifin, Drysdale, Boqvist, Shultz
G: Demko
Bench:
F: Pelletier, Noesen
D: Lundkvist, Hutson, Nikishin, Addison, Spence, York, Zamula
G: Levi, Wolf
IR: Fantilli, Sergachev
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote