stamkos

[Kwazzie]

just want to know if you guys think this is an overpayment or not before i go with a counter offer.

G A pts blks hits sog fow ppp

dynasty league, weekly lineup, 12 team h2h 25 man roster.

stamkos + cole + visnovsky

for

seguin + nash + letang

dont think its too bad of a proposition but i dont want to be blinded and sell all my depth of stars for just one big fish.

[mister_mcgoo]

well Viz is apparently seriously considering signing in the KHL so depending on what side of this you are on it might be a good idea or not

[blayze]

sorry dude just saw your PM now and noticed you already created a thread.

Stamkos is my top rated player in a keeper, but having said that I think this would be a slight overpayment.

[kevinsrangers]

might be a bit of an overpayment but you almost always have to overpay for the big fish.
i like the deal for you though.

[Kwazzie]

yeah i was leaning to making the deal and if it sets me back a year then so be it i would be stronger in the long run.. but that was with me envisioning visnovsky as a 35+ contributor for a couple seasons before he either A.) KHL bound or B.) retires. Now that this rumor is up about visnovsky departing as soon as this season its kind of just cole + stamkos for the trio.

@blayze all good man i figured screw it might as well make a thread and get as many opinions as i can if im moving so many pieces.

[hockeymanG23]

It's close. Can you receive a better D option than Visnovski?

[Kwazzie]

likely not, best i might be able to sub for is brodin or gormley, thrower

even then he seems to value his prospects quite highly.

[hockeymanG23]

likely not, best i might be able to sub for is brodin or gormley, thrower

even then he seems to value his prospects quite highly.

I think Brodin would be a significant upgrade on Vis right now. If you can sub him in then get it done. Either way, this deal will serve you well in the long run, but getting a talented young D like Brodin would make it just a bit sweeter.

[Dr. Gregg]

I would grab Stamkos. He is the best fantasy option.

Viz should not be in the equation. Easy to replace him with a waiver wire option.

[Reuben]

If this is for your middle team, with the five keepers, I suppose I'd do it b/c Stamkos IS a better bet than Seguin. But only because it makes that keeper position stronger...because I can't help but think the other two spots, for you, become much worse...albeit only over the course of one season.

Stamkos is pretty durned good, but I think Seguin is going to be awfully sweet awfully soon.

Add in that you're giving up a potential high goal guy in Nash and a top offensive dman in Letang and it would be really tough to tell you to make the trade.... unless the move is to improve that one keeper spot.

[Kwazzie]

If this is for your middle team, with the five keepers, I suppose I'd do it b/c Stamkos IS a better bet than Seguin. But only because it makes that keeper position stronger...because I can't help but think the other two spots, for you, become much worse...albeit only over the course of one season.

Stamkos is pretty durned good, but I think Seguin is going to be awfully sweet awfully soon.

Add in that you're giving up a potential high goal guy in Nash and a top offensive dman in Letang and it would be really tough to tell you to make the trade.... unless the move is to improve that one keeper spot.

it's for a different league and team not in sig... its a full keeper

[Reuben]

it's for a different league and team not in sig... its a full keeper

Ah. To be honest with you then - and I know the mantra of taking the best player, which is Stamkos - I wouldn't do it.

Stamkos > Seguin..but the gap is going to get smaller

And I can't help thinking Letang and Nash are WAY, WAY better than the two you'd be giving up.

Nash is a legit, consistent 60-70pt guy with a chance to go higher.
Letang, should he stay healthy, is in an unreal situation for the next 10years.

I'd stay pat.

[Kwazzie]

thank you everyone! i think i will pass for now on any stamkos deal, just too much to loose just for the big fish.

might go after a tier below him number 1 center