Reply With QuoteWell... it's close.
In a 5x5, those Wins are huge... and Hamels should get more Wins every year.
I also think you would get a better return for Felix.
IMO, you just trade the guy that gives you a better bat return.
King Felix or Cole Hamels?
Standard 5x5 H2H keeper league - 12 teams, 8 keepers/team
Who do you like for next year and beyond? King Felix or Hamels? I will be dealing one for a bat upgrade.
Well... it's close.
In a 5x5, those Wins are huge... and Hamels should get more Wins every year.
I also think you would get a better return for Felix.
IMO, you just trade the guy that gives you a better bat return.
very close. sure hamels more wins.
as said. trade the one - where you got best in return
Have said before that Felix is having some issues with velocity which concern me. Think Hamels is safer with him on a better team and being in the NL.
Felix by a hair
Flip a coin, this is as close as it gets.
"Be yourself; everyone else is already taken."
"Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle."
Originally Posted by djkiang
Better team?
Phillies offense is just as bad.
Texas is after Hamels.
Hamels in Texas is a downgrade.
Great hitters park.
Give me the younger guy in Safeco.
Btw on wins, last 3.5 years
Felix 50
Hamels 46
Last edited by HOOTIE; July 11, 2012 at 2:28 AM.
Likewise. The Mariners offense might be woeful, but Hernandez always seems to put himself in a position to get a W, even if the run support isn't there.
(HKYLiiga) 10-TM / H2H / Daily start keeper
G-A-PTS-PIM-PPP-SOG-HITS-W-GAA-SV%-SV-SHO
C - Tavares (K)
RW - MacKinnon (K)
LW - Ovechkin (K)
D - Letang (K)
UT - Hall (K)
G - Price (K)
The Rest:
C - Duchene / Nugent-Hopkins / Oshie
LW - Gaborik / Drouin
RW - Simmonds / Downie / Abdelkader
D - Subban / Carlson / Trouba
G - Schneider / Miller / Bernier
I just swap james shields and Matt garza for Felix. I traded for garza hoping he'd get traded and start pitching better but I didn't want to miss out on the chance of owning Felix in my keeper pool. At first I thought it may be a lot but I got both shields and garza for Dunn, lehair and dillon gee so I'm happy with Felix for that.
Better team yes, on paper. Would still rather take the Phillies offense over Seattle's that for sure. Hamels in Texas would be a downgrade yes, but still think safter than Felix this year.
Posting Permissions