Which Goalie for Remainder of Season...

[One Man Wolf Pack]

This is our last week of regular season matchups before heading into playoffs. Our trade deadline (which also equates to roster freeze) is at 3:00PM. I am rolling with 4 goalies at the moment but would prefer to drop one and pick up another winger (if I can't make a trade before 3:00PM). Here are the two goalies in questions, which one goes?

Giguere
Elliott

Team and league/scoring details in signature. There are some decent wingers left on WW (Kunitz, Brown, Max Pac, Doan, Dubinsky, Brouwer, etc.) for our scoring system.

Thanks!

[One87]

This is our last week of regular season matchups before heading into playoffs. Our trade deadline (which also equates to roster freeze) is at 3:00PM. I am rolling with 4 goalies at the moment but would prefer to drop one and pick up another winger (if I can't make a trade before 3:00PM). Here are the two goalies in questions, which one goes?

Giguere
Elliott

Team and league/scoring details in signature. There are some decent wingers left on WW (Kunitz, Brown, Max Pac, Doan, Dubinsky, Brouwer, etc.) for our scoring system.

Thanks!

I would drop JSG. Varly is playing a lot better. We all know that he's Col future and they want him to succeed. JSG is an insurance policy if/when Varly faulters. Elliott has been sharp and St.L is a timeshare, which i don't see changing. Elliott has been on of the top tenders this year, too.

[hockeyrobot]

Giggy is the easy drop here. Not only s he injury prone, but he has been outplayed by Elliott for the majority of the season.

As for who to pick up, man oh man is that a lot of cats to consider. I would go with Brown, Max or Kunitz.

[bondon]

I think it's a bit closer than it appears at first but I'd also have to go with Elliott. I think the odds of Giguere getting more starts down the stretch are a bit higher than Elliott, but Elliott has been phenomenal when plays. Should allow fewer goals and give you a higher chance of a shutout or two down the stretch as well.

As for who I'd replace him with I'd go with D Brown personally. He's got all the peripherals covered and he has the talent to put points on the board.