One Year League: Rask, Bernier or Schneider?

[PittPens1787]

Just realized both Rask and Schneider are free agents in my one-year league (not in my signature yet). My current goalies are Rinne, Price and Bernier.

I think it would make sense for me to drop a forward (Parenteau probably) and add a fourth goaltender. In a one-year league, who do you guys think is the better bet? Rask or Schneider?

With Luongo struggling so badly I'm tempted to say Schneider, but I'm sure Lu will have every opportunity to break out of this slump, as we see every year after October. Thoughts?

Thanks guys.

[joecanuck]

Even when Luongo breaks through, Schneider will still get 25-30 starts. And he has been the best goalie of the three thus far. I think he's your best bet.

[potatoetree]

Out of those three, Schneider is still the best bet. The Kings are high on Quick right now after his stellar shutout run. The Bruins are not only slumping, but also seem to just not play as offensively when Rask is in the net. Even though Luongo will probably pick it up, Schneider will still see 25 starts or so throughout the season as it is Gillis philosophy to try and give Luongo more rest.

edit: ah said it just before i did hah

[CommittedToTheIndian]

Schneider gets my vote too. The one point in Rask's favor is that I think Thomas will get a few nights off because of age whether he's playing well or not. Bernier is definitely third among those three, IMO.

[theslymonkey]

For just this year, Schneider is the clear choice. Keeper league, Rask is the easy choice.

[PittPens1787]

Thanks everyone. I think I'll drop Parenteau and add Schneider, and probably add Rask for Bernier as well. I grabbed Bernier in the draft thinking he had a shot at at least creating a goaltending controversy in LA. Quick has been too good though though.