Kipper or Quick 1 year Wins and Shutouts Only?!

[leroybrown]

Hey guys,

I'm in a 1 year points only pool. Goalie wins are worth 2 points and shutouts worth 4 points.

I currently have Kipper (CGY). Would you trade him 1 for 1 with Quick (LA) or stand pat?

PS I have Roloson (TB) what's his problem this year? Age? Drinking the wrong Koolaid down IN TB? Who would be a good goalie to target for Rolie The Goalie as Carey Price is my 3rd goalie.

Thanks for any feedback
Cheers!

[Chuk]

I would take Quick in a heartbeat.
Better offense, better defense, better team, better goalie.

[dmvincent]

Jonathan Quick for sure.

[bondon]

I would take Quick in a heartbeat.
Better offense, better defense, better team, better goalie.

Wow I could not support/emphasize this enough.

[Leetch#2]

I would go with the consensus in Quick and it's not really close

[theslymonkey]

If you are comparing Kipper to Quick, there is no question. The better goalie is Kipper, but unfortunately the team they play on has a lot to do with it. It hurts to say this, but Quick is far and away the better choice here.

Sigh, my poor Flames.