Better goalie option?

[NJDevils]

Who would be a better option in a Dynasty league? He would be my 3rd or 4th option behind Thomas and Brodeur


Cats: W, GAA, SV%, SHO

Nittymaki or Harding



thanks in advance

[NJDevils]

any thoughts?

[dmvincent]

I don't really like any of those guys but I'd probably take Harding here.

[TheRook]

Harding easily for me.

Harding has potential to be a starting goalie and his career is still in front of him. You will need someone to replace Brodeur fairly soon.

Nitty is pretty much done. He may get 25 games this year but his chances as a #1 are over. He is too injury prone. As soon as it looks like he will challenge for the starter, he gets hurt. I have a feeling he will move back to Europe after this next year also.

[dmvincent]

Harding easily for me.

Harding has potential to be a starting goalie and his career is still in front of him. You will need someone to replace Brodeur fairly soon.

Nitty is pretty much done. He may get 25 games this year but his chances as a #1 are over. He is too injury prone. As soon as it looks like he will challenge for the starter, he gets hurt. I have a feeling he will move back to Europe after this next year also.

Kuemper and Hackett are both better than him, I'm not so sure he ever finds his groove in the NHL.

[pmorrow]

I do believe Niittymaki has starter potential still but I am in the minority there. Harding is a very good goalie and going forward he's the guy you want.