Brief Keeper League evaluation...

[icevenom]

Curious what people would make of the following keeper league teams. Which is the top 5? which is the bottom 5? how am I in comparison? Our draft fills out the rest of the roster...

We run the following format:
- Head to head
- Keep only 4 (14 teams)
- Stats: G,A,+/-,PIM,SHP,PPP,GWG,SOG,FW, G/GAA/SV/SV%/SHO
- Positions: 2 C, 2 LW, 2 RW, 1 F, 3 D, 1 Util, 2 G, 4 BN, 2 IR


Team 1 (me)
C - Malkin
LW - Parise
C - E. Staal
G - Howard

Team 2
RW - Semin
RW - Gaborik
C - Stamkos
G - Bryzgalov

Team 3
LW - Kovalchuk
RW - Perry
C - Kesler
G - Luongo

Team 4
RW - Hossa
C - Roy
G - Broduer?
C - Duchene?
LW - Skinner?

Team 5
C - Getzlaf
D - Green
LW - Ryan
G - Lundqvist

Team 6
C - Backstrom
RW - Kane
LW - Marleau
G - Fleury

Team 7
D - Weber?
D - Doughty?
LW - Nash
G - Quick
LW - Kessel?
C- Plekanec?

Team 8
LW - D Sedin
C - Spezza
G - Rinne
G - Vokoun

Team 9
C - Datsyuk
LW - Franzen
G - Niemi
C - Tavares

Team 10
C - Carter
RW - Iginla
C - M Richards
G - Anderson ?
G - Thomas

Team 11
D - Keith
C - Kopitar
C - Toews
G - Halak

Team 12
C - Crosby
C - Thornton
C - B Richards
G - Price
C - Giroux?
C - Lecavalier?

Team 13
LW - Sharp
RW - St Louis
C - Zetterberg
G - Hiller
G - Kiprusoff

Team 14
LW - Heatley
LW - Ovy
C - Sedin
G - Miller
D - Byfuglien?

[bondon]

Curious what people would make of the following keeper league teams. Which is the top 5? which is the bottom 5? how am I in comparison? Our draft fills out the rest of the roster...

We run the following format:
- Head to head
- Keep only 4 (14 teams)
- Stats: G,A,+/-,PIM,SHP,PPP,GWG,SOG,FW, G/GAA/SV/SV%/SHO
- Positions: 2 C, 2 LW, 2 RW, 1 F, 3 D, 1 Util, 2 G, 4 BN, 2 IR


Team 1 (me)
C - Malkin
LW - Parise
C - E. Staal
G - Howard
Team 2
RW - Semin
RW - Gaborik
C - Stamkos
G - Bryzgalov

Team 3
LW - Kovalchuk
RW - Perry
C - Kesler
G - Luongo
Team 4
RW - Hossa
C - Roy
G - Broduer?
C - Duchene?
LW - Skinner?

Team 5
C - Getzlaf
D - Green
LW - Ryan
G - Lundqvist
Team 6
C - Backstrom
RW - Kane
LW - Marleau
G - Fleury

Team 7
D - Weber?
D - Doughty?
LW - Nash
G - Quick
LW - Kessel?
C- Plekanec?

Team 8
LW - D Sedin
C - Spezza
G - Rinne
G - Vokoun

Team 9
C - Datsyuk
LW - Franzen
G - Niemi
C - Tavares

Team 10
C - Carter
RW - Iginla
C - M Richards
G - Anderson ?
G - Thomas

Team 11
D - Keith
C - Kopitar
C - Toews
G - Halak

Team 12
C - Crosby
C - Thornton
C - B Richards
G - Price
C - Giroux?
C - Lecavalier?

Team 13
LW - Sharp
RW - St Louis
C - Zetterberg
G - Hiller
G - Kiprusoff

Team 14
LW - Heatley
LW - Ovy
C - Sedin
G - Miller
D - Byfuglien?

I bolded my favourites at first glance. DOn't understand the question marks though. Team 12 is as imbalanced as they come, but has a lot of talent. I think I like team 3 or 5 best, balanced so far and fill a lot of the categories. Team 8 did good to grab two elite goalies since goalies are heavily weighted, just not a Spezza fan personally but that team so far is pretty decent.

Your team is good as well, its just Howard that I don't trust (relative to guys like Luongo and Lundqvist)

[Pengwin7]

Team 3, 5, 12, 14 (in no particular order) would be my top 4.
Your team would be after that. 5th-7th best range.

[jhonny]

Team 3, 5, 12, 14 (in no particular order) would be my top 4.
Your team would be after that. 5th-7th best range.

I read the options... picked 3, 5, 12, and 14 as the standouts... and then I smiled when I saw that is exactly what Pengwin7 has.

I'd say your team is 5th place, and if it weren't for Howard, you might be top 2 or 3 depending on how much of a goalie upgrade you can get.