Craig Anderson vs Devan Dubnyk

[reeveta]

Next year only

Head-to-Head

Wins
GAA
SV%
Saves

Who do you prefer?

[bondon]

I would much prefer Anderson.

Will give you more W, likely better GAA, and a better Sv% and doesn't have to compete with anybody (Khabibulin who they insist on playing).

Plus pro-rated Anderson made about 2500 saves on the Sens while Dubnyk made around 2400.

[dyzfunctioned]

I'm not an Anderson fan but he's the obvious choice here.

[Shoeless]

I would take Anderson based on the Khabibulin factor for sure - I also think Anderson will put up better numbers next season regardless.

[tgraveline]

Good to know, as I may have to make this decision come the next draft for my 3rd goalie.

[WingNutUpNorth]

I'll take Dubnyk here,The Oilers will be much improved and Khabi wont be a factor as much as people think.Andy will regress back to his Avs days and it just seems Ottawa is a place where goalies go to die(I suspect Big Ev will weigh in on my comments,but this is my opinion)

[fantasyhockeygeek]

I'd be thrilled if Anderson regressed back to his Avs days... the first season, that is!

Recent career:

2009/10 (Avs): 71 GP, 38 W, GAA of 2.63, 0.917 SV%, 2047 (!) SV
2010/11 (Avs): 33 GP, 13 W, GAA of 3.28, 0.897 SV%, 858 SV
2010/11 (Sens): 18 GP, 11 W, GAA of 2.05, 0.939 SV%, 553 SV

There's enough history of good performance to convince me overlook the bad 33 GP last year with the Avs.

Dubnyk looks promising, but I'd rather Anderson.

[franklin]

I'd be thrilled if Anderson regressed back to his Avs days... the first season, that is!

Recent career:

2009/10 (Avs): 71 GP, 38 W, GAA of 2.63, 0.917 SV%, 2047 (!) SV
2010/11 (Avs): 33 GP, 13 W, GAA of 3.28, 0.897 SV%, 858 SV
2010/11 (Sens): 18 GP, 11 W, GAA of 2.05, 0.939 SV%, 553 SV

There's enough history of good performance to convince me overlook the bad 33 GP last year with the Avs.

Dubnyk looks promising, but I'd rather Anderson.

I'm with HPG here Anderson is the obvious choice. But Dubnyk improved a lot last year and could be a good sleeper.

[metaldude26]

Oh man, it has to be Anderson here. He's a proven workhorse goalie. Dubnyk has yet to cement himself as a starter. Don't expect either Ottawa or Edmonton to contend but expect much more starts and much better numbers out of Anderson.

[jspaderman]

I would take Anderson as well as Khabibulin will be a factor in Edmonton. They are not going to let that kind of salary just sit on the bench..........

[mister_mcgoo]

Anderson for sure