Possible Trade Please Evaluate

[Five for Fighting]

I am in a H2H league with the following scoring: G A +/- PIM PPG PPP SHG GWG SOG

The Following is my roster:

C Vaclav Prospal (TB - C)
C Petr Sykora (Pit - C,RW)
C Eric Staal(Car - C)
C Joe Thornton (SJ - C)
LW Zach Parise (NJ - C,LW)
LW Jason Blake (Tor - LW)
LW Thomas Vanek (Buf - LW)
RW Nathan Horton (Fla - C,RW)
RW Milan Hejduk (Col - RW) DTD
RW Martin St.Louis (TB - RW)
D Ryan Whitney (Pit - D)
D Tomas Kaberle (Tor - D)
D Kimmo Timonen (Phi - D)
D Randy Jones (Phi - D)
G Henrik Lundqvist (NYR - G)
G Dwayne Roloson (Edm - G)
G Evgeni Nabokov(SJ - G)
IR Martin Havlat (Chi - RW) IR

I have been offered: Luongo for Thorton and Nabokov

I think that I can do better, shouldn\'t I ask for Cammalleri, Zetterberg, Holmstrom or Lidstron?

Here is his roster:

C Pavel Datsyuk (Det - C)
C Michael Cammalleri (LA - C,LW)
LW Henrik Zetterberg (Det - LW)
LW Tomas Holmstrom (Det - LW)
RW Maxim Afinogenov (Buf - RW)
RW Corey Perry (Anh - RW)
D Nicklas Lidstrom (Det - D)
D Brett Clark (Col - D)
D Jaroslav Spacek (Buf - D)
D Paul Ranger (TB - D)
BN Brad Boyes (StL - C,RW)
BN Saku Koivu (Mon - C)
BN Cory Stillman (Car - LW)
G Ward, Luongo, Fleury

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated!!

[ddp]

Yes you should ask for more but the only guy that you mentioned to be fair would be Holmstrom thrown in.

[Fighting_Emu]

Unless I missed something I didnt see any goalie categories in there. It all depends on how heavily they are weighed. Even still I think this trade is the wrong move. By coming in with this original offer he has shown how high he values Luongo which is very very high. I think Nabby is a solid ace in net and although I love Bobby Lu I don\'t think he is a HUGE upgrade- definitely not thornton worthy. His numbers always sparkled and without the tandem he will take on a lot more of San Jose\'s many wins. The only concern here is of injuries but I would not even talk unless he was willing to downgrade Thornton. Just my opinion...