please choose 1 of 5 high scoring dmen

[everfeb]

e. karlsson

hughes

dahlin

fox

josi

Hey guys. Scoring...G-1pt A-1pt. That's it. Have the Draft coming up. Which 1 of these would you want in a 1 year pool. They are all pretty great. Thanks.

[redwing401959]

Josi or fox i would only lean towards Josi as he probably gives you more balance. as he will score more goals

[Axeman33]

Fox for me.

[2014olympicgold]

My order is:
Fox, Dahlin, Josi, Karlsson, Hughes.

[Eskimo Brother]

This kills me to say but Josi might be my lowest ranked of this set. Dahlin or Hughes is where I land as the top option, with 75+ potential. Fox I expect in that 70-75 range. Karlsson I could see anywhere from 65-95, but more likely in the lower half of that. Josi's now 33, with Tyson Barrie to shelter offensively on the team, and I think he may get to 70 but the upside for going past that isn't as likely as the others.

[Swarley]

I’d take Dahlin, but can’t go wrong with Fox or Hughes either

[PenguinHunter]

I am going with Fox for this year.

[metaldude26]

Fox is the most consistent, you've seen my projection for him. He's my #2 for points behind Makar.

[everfeb]

Overwhelmingly Fox so far. Not much love for Karlsson who is projected #1 points getter on Dobber Draft List

[metaldude26]

You've also got to consider that while Karlsson has IMMENSE upside (he scored 100 freaking points last season) he is also a massive injury risk and in a pool like this there is a lot of value in consistency, which Fox offers.

[Canucks_fan18]

It depends on your risk appetite and where these D fall in the draft. The hardest to predict is Karlsson. I feel this year he's the only one out of the bunch with realistic 90 point upside, but also he could be mid 60's and come's with injury risks.

I feel Fox, Dahlin and Hughes will all be 70 to 80 points. I think Fox and Hughes are slightly safer than Dahlin due to track record. In theory Buffalo could continue to rise but they could also take a step back. Again, Dahlin would be the riskiest, with perhaps the highest upside of three.

Finally, I have Josi last. I know he’s only two seasons removed of being over 90 points but with the forwards Nashville has, I don’t see how he does that again and might struggle to hit 70 points.

[RizzeeDizzee]

Fox is safest, Dahlin has huge home run potential though and not much worse downside

[everfeb]

Thanks very much guys. Took Fox. Appreciate you sharing your thoughts.