Need help picking a side...

[LiamMcNair]

League is 12 teams, Roto

Rasmuss Andersson and Moritz Seider or McAvoy and Hanifin?

Looking to upgrade my D core and can't decide between either the best player or the deeper roster.

Thanks !

[tweetdrivr]

Seider/Andersson side.

[LiamMcNair]

Thanks !

[finnys_fanatsy]

Mo and Andy

[LiamMcNair]

Mo and Andy

Can I ask you why? I thought McAvoy would be the best of the bunch and Seider has been a bit underwhelming

[finnys_fanatsy]

at the end of teh day i think McAvoy and Andersson wil be close enough in points (not sure what your other cats are..) but after you asked this question i went back and looked into my own league to see where they all are now. and i wil be honest i cant even argue my own case other than i like those two better...

MO: 29GP, 2G 10A 12Pnts, -14, 10PIM
Andy: 30GP, 4G, 16A, 20Pnts, -3, 12PIM
McAvoy: 15GP, 2G, 13A, 15Pnts, +6, 10PIM
Hanifin: 29GP, 3A, 10G 13Pnts, 0, 24PIM

those stats say to me that McAvoy and Hanifin are the tandem, but again this is just my leagues cats and no Hits or Blks..

[LiamMcNair]

at the end of teh day i think McAvoy and Andersson wil be close enough in points (not sure what your other cats are..) but after you asked this question i went back and looked into my own league to see where they all are now. and i wil be honest i cant even argue my own case other than i like those two better...

MO: 29GP, 2G 10A 12Pnts, -14, 10PIM
Andy: 30GP, 4G, 16A, 20Pnts, -3, 12PIM
McAvoy: 15GP, 2G, 13A, 15Pnts, +6, 10PIM
Hanifin: 29GP, 3A, 10G 13Pnts, 0, 24PIM

those stats say to me that McAvoy and Hanifin are the tandem, but again this is just my leagues cats and no Hits or Blks..

Ohh ok I see.

So my categories are Goals, Assists, PPP, SOG, Hits, +/-

My current D core is: Dougie Hamilton, Sergachev, Montour, and Hanifin. So I'm looking to get another D1 to pair with Hamilton in case Sergachev/Montour go back to PP1.

If that helps at all

[freedMinds]

With the Hronek injury giving Seider more minutes and Andersson locked into PP1, i'd say go with the depth.

McAvoy has been great but sooner or later Marchand is going to be getting those assists, feel like he'll slow down a bit

[finnys_fanatsy]

so...where or how do you add in Seider or McAvoy or Andersson? not sure where your going with this now.

[LiamMcNair]

so...where or how do you add in Seider or McAvoy or Andersson? not sure where your going with this now.

So Montour and Sergachev I view as pretty volatile, without PP1 time they lose a lot of value and I don't want to be holding the bag in case they both lose it.

Hanifin I view as a weak hold.

Essentially I want to improve the depth of my D core so I'm not left with only one PP1 guy in Hamilton. Would rather have Hamilton, Sergachev, Andersson, and Seider

[Axeman33]

Seider/Andersson side.

Agreed

[Bubba55]

When you talk about "core" I think long term. That being the case, Seider and Andersson are the way to go IMO.

[LiamMcNair]

When you talk about "core" I think long term. That being the case, Seider and Andersson are the way to go IMO.

Yes should have been more specific, only ever do one-year leagues !

Interesting that it seems the majority like the Andersson/Seider side.

Do you have confidence that Seider will turn it around? He's been so poor up until now, while Andersson has been much more consistent

[Bubba55]

Welcome to the forum. You probably noticed that most folks around here have a signature block where they provide all the relevant information about their team and their league. Set yourself up with one, it will help us help you.

I think most folks like the Andersson/Seider side for the same reason I did. For this year, this is going to be close. I see Seider picking things up and I don't think McAvoy is going to finish the season as a PPG D man. Rasmus and Hanifan should maintain the same pace they're on ROS. So, again, close. However, with a gun to my head I put my money on McAvoy and Hanifan for the duration. Again, it could go the other way, but it will be close regardless of what happens.

[LiamMcNair]

Welcome to the forum. You probably noticed that most folks around here have a signature block where they provide all the relevant information about their team and their league. Set yourself up with one, it will help us help you.

I think most folks like the Andersson/Seider side for the same reason I did. For this year, this is going to be close. I see Seider picking things up and I don't think McAvoy is going to finish the season as a PPG D man. Rasmus and Hanifan should maintain the same pace they're on ROS. So, again, close. However, with a gun to my head I put my money on McAvoy and Hanifan for the duration. Again, it could go the other way, but it will be close regardless of what happens.

Gotcha, thanks !