Given only the information at hand, I'd rather have Lindholm. Stankoven and York look good, but Lindholm is in the NHL and has produced at a high level. I doubt either Stankoven or York ever approach the value that Lindholm has been able to produce.
Keeper league
20 teams
G, A, P, PPP, Hits, GWG
Elias Lindholm
For
Stankoven
Cam York
Who wins and why?
Thanks
Given only the information at hand, I'd rather have Lindholm. Stankoven and York look good, but Lindholm is in the NHL and has produced at a high level. I doubt either Stankoven or York ever approach the value that Lindholm has been able to produce.
Keep Lindholm
Lindholm by a long ways and I am a huge Stankoven fan.
Lindholm is a proven producer and still young. It would take more than that !
League 1
10 team, Dynasty, points only, 30 players, keep20 starts 12 F, 6 D, 2G , unlimited prospects(can keep them max 5 years)
F: Mackinnon,Marner, Panarin, Eichel, Fiala, Hughes, Svechnikov, Robertson, Bratt, Kuznetsov, Hischier, B.Tkachuk, M.Tkachuk, Scheifele, Wheeler, Jenner, Drouin, Tatar, Colton
D:Hughes, Hamilton, Karlsson, Dunn, Burns, Theodore, Slavin, Trouba G: Shesterkin, Binnington, Vanecek
League2
Cap league (82.5M with AAV), points only, 12 teams, keep 7, (9F, 4D, 2G)
F: Hughes, Zuccarello,RNH, Marchessault, Scheifele, Toffoli, O’Reilly, Trocheck, Buchnevich extra: Marchenko
D: Makar, Dahlin, Seider, Andersson
G: Hellebuyck, Talbot
I think you get the point, trading a high end NHL player for a couple of maybe's that are two, three years down the road and maybe never. Not a good idea.
14 Team Roto; Keep 25; 12 F, 6 D, 2 G; 10 Farm; 5 Bench; 5 IR;
Salary Cap - 102.5 Mil
Scoring Cats: G, A, Pts, PIM, Hits, BS, SOG, F Points, D Points; Win+Ties+SO, GAA, SV%
Keepers
F: Aho, Larkin, DeBrincat, Vrana, Bennett, Scheifele, Kakko,Tolvanen, McBain,
D: Heiskanen, Fox, Toews, Lundqvist
G: Swayman, Andersen, Copley
Drops
F: Gaudreau, Terravainen, Puljujarvi, Kravstov, Zary
D: Brannstrom, Cernak, Alexeyev
G: Korpisalo, Merzlikins
FARM: Rossi, Berggren, Holtz, Savoie, Clarke, Tarasov, Wolf
As the others above said; Lindholm.
This isn't even close. You have a #1 NHL centre for 2 prospects. Neither of whom are consider locks or really even blue-chip prospects. Stankoven is good, like the upside, but not sure it matches up to what Lindholm has shown he can do.
York I am not super big on, or really any sort of belief he can be a legit middle 6 player. More faith in Tippett succeeding than York.
12 team Card Hockey League. Use stats from last NHL season ex: 2022-23 stats will be used for our 23-24 season cards
Fwds: MacKinnon, Pastrnak, Rantanen, M Tkachuk Scheifele, Marchand, B Nelson, Stephenson, J Toews, R Thomas, Lundell, E Rodrigues, Sissons, Lowry, M Foligno, D Guenther, Mangiapane, Pacioretty, Huberdeau, Wheeler
Dmen: Makar, D Toews, Dobson, Sergachev, S Jones, Graves, Carlo, Gudas, Byram, Girard, Thrun
Goalies: Vanecek, Francouz, Samsonov
12 teams. Keep 9 any position.
7 prospects. D scoring 3.75 for goal, 2.75 for assist. Forwards 3.5 for goal, 2.5 for assist. 0.5 for hits and blocks. Goalie scoring -1.5 GA, 0.3 for save, 2 points for win and extra 2 for shutout.
Pre Draft
F: Keller, Zegras, Suzuki, Caufield, Cozens
D: Drysdale, Guhle, Perunovich
G:
IR:
Prospects: W. Johnston, K. Johnson, Guenther, Morrow, Mateychuk
12 team Card Hockey League. Use stats from last NHL season ex: 2022-23 stats will be used for our 23-24 season cards
Fwds: MacKinnon, Pastrnak, Rantanen, M Tkachuk Scheifele, Marchand, B Nelson, Stephenson, J Toews, R Thomas, Lundell, E Rodrigues, Sissons, Lowry, M Foligno, D Guenther, Mangiapane, Pacioretty, Huberdeau, Wheeler
Dmen: Makar, D Toews, Dobson, Sergachev, S Jones, Graves, Carlo, Gudas, Byram, Girard, Thrun
Goalies: Vanecek, Francouz, Samsonov
No way I’d deal a proven consistent NHL player for the other 2.
Call me old one more time.
- Roy Kent
I'd also pass. I think York is a NHL D, but I'm not sure he's ever going to run PP1 as the primary guy. You should be able to get somebody young and producing in the NHL somewhat, plus a Stankoven/York type, at minimum.
Want a Signature? Go to Settings, and you'll find Edit Signature down the list on the left.
This thread is great lol. I’m the one with Lindholm. OP has Stankoven and York. He’s trying to push for the playoffs. I’m trying to push for Bedard. I even added in Caleb Jones and Jake Bean, which to be clear aren’t great assets but are at least relatively young guys who will contribute and would be upgrades for his team. OP ultimately declined. I know I was losing the deal but there is a non-zero benefit to not having Lindholm on my team.